BLACKWELL FAMILY Antoinette Brawn Blackwell BiographicalAunt Nettie's Reminisces, Aug. 16, 1896. After the semi-continual of Oberlin, a number of reminiscences by L.S. & others were printed in the Journal, for several weeks. On the way to Oberlin, in [46] '45 or '46, Aunt Nettie was riding in the state between Cleveland & Oberlin, they were talking about Oberlin, & a gentleman from Rochester, N.Y., a patron of Oberlin on his way there, told Aunt Nettie about Mamma, & rather warned her against Mamma, as a woman's rights woman & unorthodox. This excited Aunt Nettie's curiosity, & she asked about her as soon as she got there. By leaning forward at supper table, she could see Mamma, who sat on same side. She looked very youthful, & talked & talked away to the [a] clergyman who kept the boarding house, & Aunt Nettie thought she was rather too pronounced, talked rather too much, for so young a person. They became (not full) classmates (Aunt N. going right into 3d year), & became friends almost at once, because of natural affinity. Both were preparing for public speakers, & they were the only girls there who were. [Look up Aunt Nettie's speech at Memorial Meeting in Newark, N.J., about 3 years after death). Dress pecurliarly 2 plain & neat, & always wore smoothest & [most] nicest linen collars, wh she washed & ironed herself. Dresses were mostly calico, [wh she] always just as clean as possible - I remember seeing her wear only three that first summer - & she had an idea that sensible people wd always dress just so simply. Member of Ladies' Board held her up to the other students as example [of] for poor students - how to be very simple & economical, & yet exquisitely neat. Would no more have taken tea than wine in those days, & rebuked Aunt N. if she took an occasional cup & "Flower pot on head." At first meeting of Gen. Federation of Women's Clubs in Chicago, Aunt Nettie gave account of debating club; & at first National Council in Washington, she [you] & mother both gave reminiscences of Oberlin. Look these up. Aunt Nettie was boarding at the boarding house, & Mamma at3 Prof. Whipple's; but Aunt Nettie used to slip over sometimes to sleep with Mamma, - with connivance of some of the faculty, who trusted them. She was kind to all the colored men- very loyal in antislavery matters - and she darned the stockings of a young white man, and he dropped the letter in which she offered to do it, if he wd bring them to her; and everybody thought he did it on purpose. She kept portraits of Garrison, Parker, Gerrit Smith &c in her room, & always praised them & stood by them, though they were unpopular. Could always ridicule & laugh a certain nervous & fidgetty colored man out of his fads (the one who threatened to cut his throat). Colored people all thought a great deal of her. "Because she was a Garrisonian?" A.S.B. "Because she was herself," Aunt N. She was fond of everything except composition - writing; she wrote them because she had to, but did not care for it. 4 Made them brief & terse. Good in all her studies. Was very prompt, & used to lecture Aunt N. for being untidy & absent-minded, & not caring. Aunt N. had stain on her dress & did not know how to get it out; [Ma?} told Mamma so when she spoke to her about it: & Mamma said "Oh, Nettie, soap & water will take out grease spots!" First year Aunt N. was there, [she was] Mamma boarded for some months at boarding hall [school]; next year when they were both seniors at Prof. Whipple's. Sarah Pellett night have letters of Mamma's. Lives in one of the Brookfields. Mamma came back to Oberlin after she had graduated, while Aunt Nettie & Sarah Pellett were still there - She was on her way to speak somewhere in Ohio. She made only a short stay, & Sarah was rather vexed that she would not stayover another day. [M] They 5 all three slept together; Mamma was tired with her journey, & after she had gone to sleep (as they supposed) Sarah Pellett said, "She is always in a hurry. She is like her father; he was always in a hurry & pushing things through." Mamma heard & was vexed. She was practical; understood all sorts of household work; could sew &c. Could tell you how to do things. Was never a bit afraid to speak her mind, when she either approved or disapproved of what people were doing. Aunt N. & Mamma took a walk at sunset one day & talked over what would be possible for women (no one had done anything as yet but Abby Kelly & the Grimkes; it was all in the air), & Aunt N. had made up her mind what she would do, & she 6 asked Mamma if she thought it would be possible for a woman to be a minister, & Mamma said she thought not. When they were each the mother of one baby, they were talking of matrimony one day, & Aaron Powell was there. Aunt Nettie said, "Marriage is not a necessity," & Mamma turned & said emphatically. "Nettie, marriage is a necessity." She heartily approved of Aunt Nettie's marrying. Aunt Nettie's Reminiscences of Mamma at Oberlin & elsewhere. Rev. Antoinette L. Brown Blackwell, D. D., the first woman to be ordained a minister, was educated at Oberlin. Antoinette Brown was born in a log cabin at [in] Henrietta, N. Y., on May 20, [184] 1825. Before she was sixteen she began to teach school, receiving a dollar a week and "boarding around." She [was] longed to go to college, and cherished the hope of becoming a minister. Her parents and her brother thought it impossible. Her mother urged her to go as a foreign missionary instead. [She prepared for her daughter all the] Antoinette stuck to her plan, and finally got her father's [?] to go to Oberlin. Before she arrived [there] she was warned against a [young] student there named Lucy Stone, who was promulgating dangerous and radical ideas; but the two young wom soon became great friends, [and later in] a friendship cemented later in life by their marrying brothers. Antoinette entered the Ladies' Literary [?] in the [Junior L] junior year, and was graduated in 1847, with Lucy, who was in the regular classical course. The account of their organizing the first debating society ever formed among2 college girls has already been given. In Antoinette's senior year, a rumor got abroad that she meant to study theology, and she was summoned before Mrs. Finney and several members of the Ladies' Board; [who plead] They pleaded with her earnestly to give up so wild a notion. After quoting many persons who thought women ought not to preach, Mrs. Finney said, "You certainly will never have the courage to put your opinion against that of all these wise, good men!" Antoinette answered, "Prof. Finney has done just that,-"referring to his [differin] dissenting from the orthodoxy of his day. And she added, "What he has done, why cannot I do?" The students had to write essays. During her senior year in the literary course, Antoinette wrote [an two] an exegesis dealing with the texts, "I suffer not a woman to teach," and, "If the woman would know anything, let them ask their husbands at home." President Mahan heard of it. He was the most liberal of the faculty He sent for [the] her essay, and published it in the Oberlin Quarterly Review, [of which he was the editor] while she was still an undergraduate. He was editor of the Review. Prof. Fairchild was the assistant editor, and he wrote for the same issue an article on the orthodox side of the woman question. "When he came to the boarding house to see me, we could not help 3 laughing in each other's faces," said Antoinette, in telling of it, long after. "He had been my brother's classmate, his sister was mine. We were well acquainted, and he was as kind as kind could be, but determined in his overview. [Later] Years later, when I joined the Unitarians, they wondered if I had done anything for which I had to leave the Orthodox fold, and they asked me for a letter of recommendation. I applied to Prof. Fairchild, who had [was] then become President Fairchild, and he gave me a beautiful one. The Oberlin men were the most kindly and generous possible in criticising and helping on people who trod on their tenderest feelings, as Lucy and I did. The Oberlin women were much less so. Prof. Morgan, Professor of Old Testament Literature and Theology, spent a whole class session discussing my paper and trying to show me that I was not altogether right. Prof. Finney said afterwards that he believed [thought] there were some women divinely ordained to preach, and that I might be one of them. "He was very kind, and gave me the benefit of the doubt." After she had been graduated from the literary course, her father and brother renewed their efforts to dissuade [dissen]4 from entering the theological school, and refused her any financial help. Miss Adams, the lady principal at Oberlin, then promised to get her [some] enough teaching to do in the preparatory department of the college to [help] pay half the expenses of her theological course. But Miss Adams fell ill, and in her absence the Ladies' Board (composed principally of the professors' wives, and strongly opposed to women ministers) made a rule that no graduate of the college should be allowed to teach in the preparatory [girls] department or in the lower classes. This was done on purpose to bar her out. [Then But] Thereupon Miss Atkins, the assistant principal, got up a private drawing class for Antoinette, who had for some time taught drawing in the lower school. Her class included Prof[essor (afterwards President)] Fairchild and a number of the theological students, and proved no profitable that it enabled her to meet all her expenses. When the theological school [afar] opened, each student, as part of the literary [exercises] work, had in turn to read an essay, to take part in a discussion, and to give a sermon or oration. [The students made up the list of those] Antoinette's essay [was received] passed without objection. But when it was her turn to take part in a discussion - to "speak in public" - [there was] the trouble began The students themselves made up the programs for these discussions. They handed the list, with her name on it, to Prof. Morgan. He was the kindest of the professors, but also the most bigoted on the woman question. His face flushed [as] and his voice trembled as he read the hit. The young men who had prepared it were ordered to stay after class. Then the professor said to [asked] them, "Why did you make that appointment, 5 when you knew I did not believe in having women speak?" They answered, "Why, our constitution requires every student to do it." "I'll see about that. You can go." he said, curtly. Some [A] time passed. Rumor said there was faculty meeting after faculty meeting. [But when] Oberlin College had been founded with an express proviso that all its opportunities should be open to women. [thought] It had never occurred to anyone that women might wish to [study the] go through the theological school, but there was no way to keep them out. "I went to the class not knowing what to expect," said Antoinette, in telling the story later. "But the [dear] dear old professor said, before the [ela] lesson began: 'Antoinette, I believe you are wrong. I should stop you in this if I could. But I have no authority to do it. I shall give you the very best instruction that I can while you are my pupil.' And he did, all through the three years." That was in 1848. When Oberlin celebrated its semicenntennial many years later, Antoinette was among the invited speakers [there]. Prof. Morgan was the only one of the old professors left. He was very old and feeble. He spoke to her very kindly, laid his hand on her head, and his last words to her were, "Dear child, God bless you!" Some of the [theological] students had been local4. from entering the theological school, and refused her any financial help. [handwritten] Miss Adams, the lady principal at Oberlin, then promised to get her enough teaching to do in the preparoty department of the college to pay half the expenses of her theological course. But Miss Adams fell ill, and in her absence the Ladies' Board (composed principally of the professors' wives, and strongly opposed to women ministers) made a rule that no graduate of the college should be allowed to teach in the preparatory department or in the lower classes. This was done on purpose to bar her out. Therefore Miss Atkins, the assistant principal, got up a private drawing class for Antoinette, who had for some time taught drawing in the lower school. Her class included Prof Fairchild and a number of the theological students, and proved so profitable that it enabled her to meet all her expenses. When the theological school opened, each student, as part of the literary work, had in turn to read an essay, to take part in a dis- cussion, and to give a sermon or oration. Antoniette's essay passed without objection. But when it was her turn to take part in a discussion - to "speak in public" - the trouble began. The students themselves made up the programs for these discussions. They handed the list, with her name on it, to Prof. Morgan. He was the kindest of the professors, but also the most bigoted on the woman question. His face flushed and his voice trembled as he read the hit. The young men who had prepared it were ordered to stay after class. Then the professor said to them, "Why did you make that appoint- 5. ment, when you knew I did not believe in having women speak?" They answered, "Why, over constitution requires every student to do it." "I'll see about that. You can go." he said, curtly, some little time passed. Rumor said there was faculty meeting after faculty meeting. Oberlin College had been founded with an express proviso [?] that all its opportunities should be open to women. It had never ocurred to anyone that women might wish to go through the theological school, but there was no way to keep them out. "I went to the class not knowing what to expect", said. Antoniette, in telling the story later. "But the dear old professor said, before the lesson began: Antoniette, I believe you are wrong. I should stop you in this if I could. But I have no authority to do it. I shall give you the very best instruction that I can while you are my pupil". And he did, all through the three years." That was in 1848. When Oberlin celebrated its semicentennial many years later Antoniette was among the invited speakers. Prof. Morgan was the only one of the old professors left. He was very old and feeble. He spoke to her very kindly laid his hand on her head, and his last words to her were, "Dear child, God bless you!" Some of the students had been local6 preachers before entering the theological school. They asked for a student's license to preach, and so did she. They granted licenses to all the young men, and told Antoniette that she might act on her own responsibility. So she began to preach and lecture occasionally. Her first sermon was given in a school house in Henrietta, Ohio. One of her class mates, a young man, went with her and led the singing. She received many marks of good will [much kindness] from her fellow students. [Lettice] Another young woman, Lettice Smith (Holmes) was also following the [theological] course, but never took part in any speaking. During their three years in the theological school, the names of these two young women were never published with those of the other students, but [in a [?] with a break between and] were marked with a star and the words "Resident graduates [students] pursuing the theological course". [and] When the catalogue came out after they got through, [they] their names were left out entirely, and continued to be left out of the list of graduates for about 40 years. Then they were put in as full-fledged graduates of the theological [graduate] school. Although the faculty at the close of her course did not recognize Antoinette as a graduate, many people in the town felt a great deal of sympathy with her, including one of the founders of 7 the college, Father Kemp. Some of her classmates who had always stood by her went to Father Kemp and proposed that she should be ordained, along with a young man in the class who was going out as a foreign missionary; and they hunted up enough other ministers who were in favor to fill out [arrange] an ordination service. But Antoinette thought it would be ungrateful on her part to take the Oberlin church for her ordination, when the faculty so decidedly disapproved of her entering the ministry; and she refused. A Mrs. Barnes, of New York, who had often attended the lectures and recitations at the theological school, offered Antoinette a good salary if she would work for a social purity society in New York and do missionary work there. She did so for a time; but the ladies were shocked by her attending and speaking at the first National Woman's Rights Convention held at Worcester, Mass., in 1850); and after that she worked as a free lance, lecturing and preaching where she could. Channing, Garrison, Gerrit Smith, Samuel May and others helped her to opportunities. She went all through New York State with [?] [?ony], holding meetings in behalf of woman's rights; and she wrote much for the papers and magazines. Horace Greeley and Charles A. Dana offered to engage a hall and give her $1000 a year and her board (an almost unheard of salary for a woman at that time) if she would preach regularly in New York City. But she felt in her modesty8 that she was too young and inexperienced [for a metropolitan pulpit. She declined the offer] to support the responsibilities of a great metropolitan pastorate. Instead, she accepted a call from the Congregational church at South Butler, N.Y., with a salary of $300. a year. Here she was regularly ordained as an orthodox Congregational minister in 1853. The event called down tremendous denunciation from pulpit and press. Dr. Cheever declared that any woman who would let herself be ordained was an infidel, and any church that would ordain her was an infidel church. She was appointed by her church a delegate to the World's Temperance Convention in New York, a convention composed largely of ministers. Her credentials were accepted, but when she rose to speak the convention went into a prodigious uproar which drowned her voice. This lasted two days. Despite the efforts made in her behalf by Channing, Phillips, Garrison, Powell and others, including Neal Dow, the president of the Convention, she was not allowed to be heard. A period of religious doubt led her to resign her pulpit. She emerged 9 from this season of darkness a Unitarian, and her faith has ever since been steady and unclouded. Soon after she married Samuel C. Blackwell, resigning her pastorate, a brother of [the Doctors Elizabeth and Emily] Dr. Elizabeth Blackwell, the earliest woman physician, and of Henry B. Blackwell, who had married, a few years before, her college friend, Lucy Stone. The cares of bringing up a large family made regular pastoral work impossible, but she has always preached and lectured as she had opportunity. [A beautiful girl in her youth, she is now a handsome and cheery grandmother in great demand] She [and] was one of the most active workers with Julia Ward Howe in the Association for the Advancement of Woman, which for many years held its annual Congresses all over the country. A beautiful girl in her youth, and gifted with a singularly buoyant and serene temperament, she is now a handsome and cheery grandmother. At he age of 88, she still preaches an occasional sermon10. with much acceptance in [her home] [town] the Unitarian church of Elizabeth N.J., where she resides with a married daughter. She is the author of several philosophical works, one of which [them, the] "The sexes throughout Nature", contains interesting reminiscences of her life at Oberlin. She has also written a novel and a volume of poems. Oberlin has given her [an] unsolicited and honorary degree of A.M. [and] It also offered her an A. B. which she declined. A few years ago it made her a [D.D.] Doctor of Divinity, thus royally atoning for its conservatism of more [more] [than] than sixty years ago.Antoinette L. Barrow Blackwell's Reminiscences (Notes taken by A.S. Blackwell) Aug. 19, 1903 [Aunt Nettie said Mamma's] Lucy's friends at Oberlin were more boys than girls, though her most intimate friends were [Aunt Nettie] Antoinette Brown and Sarah Pellet. Others were Lettice Smith, Emmeline French, "poor thing", she was rather lawless; she was expelled, or quietly slid out, from Oberlin, really because she was not a Christian. They said they had never had a graduate who was not a Christian. She did something lawless which would have given them a chance to expel her. But we all thought that if she would only have professed to be a Christian, she would have been allowed to remain." Eliza Fairchild, Helen Cook, Lucy liked Sarah Pellet, and got her to go to Oberlin Herman Hall was " like Edith" omit- an excellent man, bit shy and lacking self-confidence. Went as a missionary, and married, and then came back to Oberlin. Prof. Finney at his recitations used to mix up the names of all the class in hishat, turn his head away and draw one and call on that one to recite, but I think he wanted to develop Herman Hall, and also to call out the only woman in the class; and Antoinette thinks he held their names in his hand; anyway,he called them up so often that Thomas Holmes told him it seemed to him that "Herman and Antoinette got drawn too often" and they were not drawn so often afterwards. Thomas Holmes and Lettice Smith were from Michigan; they took the four years course, then married, and came back and took the divinity course together. She washed and worked her way through college the first four years and would not take any money from him, or even let him make her any presents. She worked in President Fairchild's family. Her husband approved of her studying theology, and said it would be the happiest day of his life when she began to preach.She afterwards taught at Antioch College, studied abroad, and helped her husband for years in his parish at Chelsea, Mich. She was a very good student, but found students in the "Ladies' Literary Course", and those in the "Regular Classical Course", recited almost everything together. These were just a few things that they had separately. Mamma and Aunt Nettie went to the theological school which took three years more. " They had confidence in us", said Aunt Nettie; and in proof of it she mentioned that she was allowed to leave the girls' dormitory (the Ladies' Boarding Hall) at night, go through Tappan Hall, which was then the men's dormitory, and join Mamma in her room, and spend the night with her; and they lay awake and talked about all sorts of things. She thinks that Mamma at this time was boarding in the family of one of the officials of the colleges. Miss Adams, the lady principal, was a pleasant person, very light as to complexion and hair, and so careful of her skin that she had soft water to wash in. She had had anoffer of marriage from one of the finest professors at Oberlin, but had refused him. Later she had an offer from one of the younger men - a theologue, and she was interested in him. She got Aunt Nettie to come and sit by her at the table. The young man talked a great deal; he liked to discuss, and so did Aunt Nettie; and Miss Adams would sit in silence and listen. She was trying him out. Aunt Nettie thinks Miss Adams invited her to sit with her on purpose. Miss Adams married him, but it did not turn out very happily. He was too overbearing, did not appreciate enough what she was, and wanted himself to be head and front of everything.Antoinette L. Brown Blackwell's Reminiscences. Notes taken by Alice Stone Blackwell, Aug. 19, 1903 Lucy's friends at Oberlin were more boys than girls, though her most intimate friends were Antoinette Brown and Sarah Pellet. Others were Letitia Smith, Emmeline French, "poor thing, she was rather lawless; she was expelled, or quietly slid out, from Oberlin, really because she was not a Christian. They said they had never had a graduate who was not a Christian. She did something lawless which would have given them a chance to expel her. But we all thought that if she would only have professed to be a Christian, she would have been allowed to remain". Eliza Fairchild, Helen Cook, Lucy liked Sarah Pellet, and got her to go to Oberlin. Herman Hall was an excellent man, but shy and lacking self-confidence. Went as a missionary and married, and then came back to Oberlin. Prof. Finney at his recitations used to mix up the names of all the class in his hat, turn his head away and draw one and call on that one to recite; but I think he wanted to develop Herbert Hall, and also to call out the only woman in the class; and Antoinette thinks he held their names in his hands; anyway, he called them up so often that Thomas Holmes told him it seemed to him that Herman and Antoinette got drawn too often and they were not drawn so often afterwards. Thomas Holmes and Lettice Smith were from Michigan; they took the four years' course, then married, and came back and took the divinity course together. She washed and worked her way through college the first four years, and would not take any money from him, or even let him make her any presents. She worked in President Fairchild's family. Her husband approved of her studying theology, and said it would be the happiest day of his life when she began to preach. She afterwards taught at Antioch College, studied abroad, and helped her husband for years in his parish at Chelsea, Mich. She was a very good student, but found it hard to express herself. Prof. Finney's first wife was a conservative, and labored with Lucy and Antoinette against becoming lecturers or preachers. His second wife was much more liberal, and he liberalized under her influence. Once in Brooklyn, when Prof. Finney and the second Mrs. Finney and Antoinette were walking up and down, he was cautioning Antoinette against becoming too ultra a Garrisonian and unorthodox, and to be very prudent and maidenly, etc. - a nice fatherly talk, only he was a little fidgetty lest she might get off the track somehow, and Mrs. Finny said, "Antoinette, follow your own convictions," and he grinned and said nothing.Antoinette L. Brown entered Oberlin in the third year of the "Ladies Literary Course". She says: "The students were those who had come to learn, not because they were sent by parents to obtain a fashionable education. Few colleges could show a better record for thoroughness. Many of the students were older than college students of today, and not a few had been preachers or teachers of considerable experience before coming to Oberlin. Many of them taught in the preparatory department, then much larger than the college. The closest and most cordial relations existed between the people of the village, the school, and the faculty, which has continued to this day."Antoinette Brown Blackwell "reminisced" and A. S. B. noted down what she said: "What a hard time I had financially at Oberlin!" It was just after she had finished her regular college studies, and wanted to study theology, and was preparing by studying Hebrew in the long vacation. Her father had said he had spent as much on her education as on that of any of his other children, and could do no more. He wanted to prevent and switch her off from theology, knowing how hard it would be. Her brothers also disapproved of her studying theology, and would not help her. Mr. Peter Moyers, of Rochester, Michigan, the principal of a school in Michigan where she had taught the previous vacation for weeks (and who was very anxious to have her come back there and teach) promised to stand behind her financially, and she went on with her study of Hebrew, trusting to that. Then he suddenly died. Miss Adams, the lady principal at Oberlin, was very kind and friendly and sympathized with Antoinette and promised that she should be allowed to do enough teaching in the institution to pay half her expenses. Then Miss Adams fell ill, and while she was ill the rest of the Ladies' Board being strongly opposed to Antoinette's studying theology, and determined to drive her back to teach at that place in Michigan, where they knew she was desired, got together and voted not to give her any teaching - that the teaching in the college must all be done by undergraduates! She was in despair, having no one to stand by her. Then Miss Atkins, the assistant principal, advised her to give lessons in drawing, and promised to get her pupils; and by this she was able to pay all her expenses, working only half as long hours as she would have done if teaching in the institution. Miss Atkins was a very sweet person; had lost her lover and would not marry for a long time, but finally did. Antoinette had among her pupils a number of the theological students and one of the Professors - Prof. Fairchild, who was afterwards president of the college said: "It showed on which side their sympathies were". When Antoinette went to Oberlin she was put in a back room with no view but a woodpile and back places. She made a sketch of the woodpile from the window, and when she was doing it Miss Adams came in. She tried to hide the sketch, but too late. Miss Adams saw it, and she was at once made teacher of drawing to the girls of the lower classes, and among other girls who chose to come in to the drawing class. Later she was appointed to teach a composition class. So when this straitness of means for her theological course arrived, she had already been teaching drawing.Aunt Nettie's Reminiscences - Summer of 1918 Mamma at Oberlin used to mind the clothes of the students, both white and colored. Aunt Nettie did not, as she disliked sewing. When Aunt Nettie was on her way to Oberlin in the stage-coach, she had for a fellow passenger a trustee of the college, from Rochester, who knew her family. He told her that there was one young woman at Oberlin named Lucy Stone, who was a good scholar, and had nothing objectable in her behaviour, but who held wild and radiant ideas on religion and other objects; and he advised Aunt Nettie that to become intimate with her. This excited her curiousity; and the first person she inquired about after she get there was Lucy Stone. Mamma was pointed out to her, in the dining room. She was sitting not far form Aunt Nettie, and just across the aisle. (the men and women sat on opposite sides of long tables). Mamma was talking with the man who had change of the boarding hall and with Nelson Cox (afterwards "Sunset Cox"), and she was laying down the law to them, and as she looked liked a girl of seventeen, with her small figure, hair cut short (as many of the young girls wore it then), her rosy cheeks and bright smile, Aunt Nettie thought she was taking too much upon herself for so young a girl; but when she learned that Mamma was 27, she thought it was all right. Mamma and Aunt Nettie each spent five years at Oberlin, but they were only two years together. Mamma was there three years before she came. Mamma spent one year in the preparatory department, Aunt Nettie says. Aunt Nettie entered in the Junior year. They were supposed to be taking different courses, but the college was small and poor, and the it hard to express herself. Prof. Finneys's first wife was a conservative, and labored with Lucy and Antoinette, against becoming lecturers or preachers. His second wife was much more liberal, and he liberalized under her influence. Once in Brooklyn, when Prof. Finney and the second Mrs. Finney and Antoinette were walking up and down, he was cautioning Antoinette against becoming too ultra a Garrisonian and unorthidox, and to be very prudent and maidenly etc- a nice fatherly talk, only he was a little fidgetty list she might get off the track somehow, and Mrs. Finney said " Antoinette, follow your own convictions, " and be grinned" and said nothing.