NAWSA SUBJECT FILE Boyer, Ida Porter BOSTON TRAVELER, FRIDAY, MARCH 14, 1952 Memorial Services for Mrs. Ida Boyer Memorial services for Mrs. Ida Porter Boyer, 92, pioneer in the woman suffrage movement, will be held at the Newton cemetery chapel Tuesday at 4 P.M. Mrs. Boyer, a native of Middleport, Pa., died yesterday at the home of her son, Richard P. Boyer, 100 Madison Avenue, Newtonville. Mrs. Boyer, who gave public lectures on current events until she was 75, served as campaign manager in the drive for women's rights to vote in several states. The drive succeeded at the time in Louisiana, Oklahoma, Oregon and Wyoming. She leaves, besides her son, three sisters, Mrs. John Aston of West Chester, Pa., Mrs. Gertrude Kennedy of Sheridan, Wyo.,, and Mrs. E. R. Wilson of Fairlington, Va.; a grandson and three great- grandchildren. [*Boston Post Jan 8 1920*] WOMEN GET POINTS ON BALLOTING Voting School Course Gives Instruction in Suffrage The vote is an expression of conscience. The choice of a party and the casting of a vote is a solemn act at the altar of citizenship." This is what Mrs. Ida Porter Boyer told the women instructors in manual training at the Sloyd Training School on Harcourt street, who, as prospective women voters, are her pupils in citizenship. With a huge political party chart hanging on the wall behind her and a pointer in her hand, Mrs. Boyer presided as teacher of the voting school. PARTY AFFILIATION "The choice of affiliation with either of the great political parties involves sentiment and tradition and depends largely upon temperament and type of mind," said Mrs. Boyer. "If temperamentally you see the people before all else, you are a democrat. If the nation looms largest in your mind you are a republican. "Democrat comes from a Greek word that means 'people.' The Democrats believe in the individual rights of people and the rights of individual states. The Republicans would have a strongly centralized national government. Since Washington's time the Democratic party of today, has stood for low tariff. The Federalist party of the old days, which has become the Republican party of today, stood for a protective tariff." Tracing on her chart by a red line the picture of America's political pathway from the establishment of the nation until the present, Mrs. Boyer dwelt briefly on each President, bringing out the significant events of their administrations as they touched upon the popularity of political parties. "Every good citizen today ought to know the soul of the Monroe Doctrine," she maintained. "A League of Nations was formed 'way back in 1815, called the Holy Alliance, when Europe was as much in dread of Napoleon as they are today of Germany. Briefly, the substance of the doctrine set down by President Monroe declared that any attempt of a foreign power to gain foothold in the western hemisphere was to be regarded by the United States as an unfriendly act. This meant that the United States would take up arms should there be an attempt to invade Canada, Mexico, Central or South America." Brookline Chronicle mar. 27, 1920 SECOND OF LECTURES FOR WOMEN VOTERS ------------------------------------------------ Mrs. Porter-Boyer Gives History of Political Parties in Country ---------------------------------------------------------------- The second in the series of four talks on "Government" arranged by the Brookline Equal Suffrage Association, was given at the Public Library Wednesday afternoon by Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer, who took for her subject "Political Parties -- Past and Present." The talk proved to be as enjoyable and instructive as the first had been. Listening to every word, her audience showed her appreciating of her careful and very clear exposition of the formation of the political parties of our country. The speaker displayed a chart showing the political pathway from 1789 to 1920. In explaining this she said in part: "When Washington became president there were few political differences; the Whigs or Radicals and the Tories, as few emissaries of the crown or clerks in official capacity here. There were only 2,000 voters in New England at that time. During Washington's administration differences of opinion began to arise, and these differences were the cause of the formation of new parties. The first, called the Democratic Republican, broke away from the Federalist on the question of tariff and elected Jefferson as its standard bearer. The next important party was the Democratic, which believed in states' rights, which raised the question of slavery in the new states; this question formed a new party called the Whig, which elected Harrison, as against slavery in the new states. "With some swinging of the pendulum from one to the other a strong party grew from the Whigs, called the Republican, which drew over many Democrats on the policy of absolute abolition of slavery. This party elected President Lincoln. This question being finally settled in 1864 through the Civil War, the two great parties, Republican and Democratic, remained in existence. The differences between them were more or less temperamental or candid by environment or in the states by a matter of self-interest in regard to industries." The subject of the third talk to be given at the Library next Wednesday afternoon at three o'clock will be "Citizenship -- Who are and Who May be Citizens -- Naturalization, Registration, and Voting -- Convention and Primary Systems." April 3, 1920 THIRD OF LECTURES FOR WOMEN VOTERS ----------------------------------------------------- Mrs. Porter-Boyer Tells of Citizenship, Naturalization, and Voting -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Another attentive audience gathered in the Lecture Hall of the Brookline Public Library Wednesday afternoon for the third of the series of "Talks on Government" by Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer, arranged by the Brookline Equal Suffrage Association. Mrs. Robert H. Schacht presided and remarked that, while the third lecture would undoubtedly be of profound interest to the women who so soon expect to exercise the privilege of citizenship, yet the fourth and last talk next Wednesday, Mrs. Boyer thinks, will be the most interesting of all. Mrs. Boyer must be heard in order to appreciate the vivacity, the clearness, the masterly style with which she discourses upon her theme, enlivening it here and there with touches of wit and humor. Where a less gifted speaker would make it a dry subject indeed, she succeeds in holding the absorbed attention of her hearers from the first to the last word. Before beginning her lecture Mrs. Boyer held up a volume of the Manual of the General Court and suggested to her audience that the procure the book from the clerk of the Document Room at the State House, "as it contains a great deal of valuable information about the State, Government, Congressional and Representative Districts, etc." She took for her subject, "Citizenship, Who Are and Who May be Citizens. -- Naturalization, Registration, and Voting -- Convention and Primary Systems," and spoke in part as follows: "In regard to voting there are certain qualifications reserved by each state in its constitution. Massachusetts has the educational qualification. The qualifications are different in each state. Here I must digress a little to tell you an interesting bit of state history. Massachusetts was formed by two Colonies -- the Plymouth and the Massachusetts Bay, which combined in 1691. Governor Winthrop of the Massachusetts Bay Colony and Governor Bradford of the Plymouth Colony each kept a diary or 'Journal of Proceedings' which tell of the early days of the colonies. Governor Winthrop's diary comprised three volumes, that of Governor Bradford had two. In these diaries we find the beginnings of our citizenship. A strange incident was the disappearance for over one hundred years of the third volume of Governor Winthrop's diary, while the second volume of Governor Bradford's was lost for almost as long. In 1850 a man who was reading a certain book, noticed that it contained a statement which convinced him that the author must have had access to Governor Bradford's lost manuscript. Communication was established with the author and the valuable document was located in the library of the Bishop of London. The Bishop would not allow the diary to be taken away, saying that it belonged to the Bishopric, but he did permit a minute copy to be made. The third volume of Governor Winthrop's Journal was discovered in the tower of the Old South Church, where, during the Revolution, the pastor, the Rev. Thomas Prince, had his study, to which spot he had moved it when the British soldiers turned the church into a riding school. The Massachusetts Historical Society has copies of these valuable old documents. "The essentials of registration are that the voter must have lived in Massachusetts one year, and in the same place six months. It is of far greater importance that a voter vote at the primaries than at the election, for at the primaries the candidates for the various offices are selected according to the number of votes cast for them. Therefore a voter should not complain about the fitness of any candidate if he himself has failed to do his duty at the primaries. The term 'Independent Voter' is loosely used. There is no uch thing at the primaries. You must specify some party or you will receive no ballot. At the primaries you select the man whom you wish to place on your party ticket. At a Convention the candidates are selected by the delegates to the Convention." At this point Mrs. Boyer displayed sample ballots of the Republican, the Democratic, and Socialist parties for the primaries in 1918 and explained how they should be marked. "At a state election you may vote for a Republican Governor and a Democratic Lieutenant-Governor if you wish to. Pick out what you want when you are alone in the booth, with your conscience and your lead pencil. Then you have performed the highest sacrament of citizenship. One reason why I think that women will become a great leavening power when they enter the electorate is because I believe that they will thoroughly thrash out the pros and cons of the value of various measures, the abilities of candidates , etc., before they vote. The voting age is twenty-one years and upwards. "The Amendments to be voted on in this state are printed on the same sheet with the names of the candidates. In some states they are printed on a separate sheet which affords a chance for manipulation. "The Fourteenth Amendment states that all persons born or naturalized in the United States are citizens thereof. This does not hold good of women. If a woman marries a foreigner she loses her citizenship. Ancestry does not count. The marriage ceremony compeis the woman to take the citizenship of her husband. She may not be able to speak a word of French, yet she is declared to be a Frenchwoman; it may be impossible for her to read a laundry ticket, yet she is considered Chinese. A striking example of this unjust law is the case of Frances Scoville who lived in Topeka, Kansas. While traveling in France she met and married Mr. Mumm, whose ancestral castle was on the German side of the Rhine. When the Great War broke out, she implored Mr. Mumm to join the Allies, but he replied that he intended to remain in Germany. Frances Scoville Mumm managed to secure a passport and returned alone to the United States, only to find that all her Kansas property had been confiscated because the law made her an alien and she no longer owned a foot of land. A bill has been introduced into Congress that her property be restored to her. She cannot become naturalized because the law requires the Keene N.H. Nov 20, 1920 WOMAN AUTHORITY EXPLAINS CONDITIONS ------------------------------------ Mrs. Porter Boyer Gives Interesting Address Before Woman's Club ---------------------------------------------------------- Mere man is not going to stand alone on the pedestal of local politics. Women of the city and particularly members of the Keene Woman's club are going to see to it that they have a say in matters political at every opportunity. This fact may be readily taken for granted after listening to the address of Mrs. Porter Boyer of Boston before the club at Wildey hall yesterday afternoon and noting the interest and enthusiasm displayed by the members in every detail of the speaker's discourse. Mrs. Boyer proved herself a live-wire orator and she had a live-wire audience, a combination which made possible one of the most entertaining meetings of the organization since its inception. The president, Mrs. Robert P. Hayward, presided. Mrs. Boyer's talk was given in an engaging conversational tone and was of the type that would have pleased every woman voter in the city, not merely for the entertainment it provided , but also for its educational value to the sex. She gave a complete history of the Republican, Democratic and Non-Partisan parties, without favoring either, advanced her opinion cleverly as to why the G.O.P. landslide nearly obliterated the opposing factions at the recent elections, compared the present era with the after math of Civil war days, and incidentally took a fling at the high cost of living and excessive taxes of the present time. "It's like going to church in a new city or town for women who try to find out which party to join," said Mrs. Boyer, in speaking of the part her sex took in the presidential election. "We are first asked to go to a certain church. If we do attend that church two or three times, it is practically certain we shall always do so. The same applies to politics so far as women are concerned. The first choice will probably always be followed if the party is functioning for the best interests of the country and the people." Mrs. Boyer also intimated that women like to be "invited" to affiliate themselves politically just as much as they do to social functions. As evidence of this she told of work done by Republican workers among the women of Boston, who made a thorough canvass of the woman voters while the Democrats did not. The answer invariably received by the workers when they asked a woman to join, Mrs. Boyer said, was ."Yes, I guess I will vote the Republican ticket. Not representative of any other party has asked me to do so." In discussing the high cost of living it appeared that every member was made to feel that she was being addressed individually when the speaker suddenly remarked: "Remember those stockings we used to buy for 30 cents we now wear and pay a dollar for? The stockings are no better, but the price has advanced and we worry ourselves foolish asking for the reason. Many of us do not know that a large part of the difference is only a tax, which is being paid as our contribution to the war debt." The victory of the Republicans all over the country, Mrs. Boyer stated, was simply a protest , not by Republicans alone but by voters of other parties, against the one in power. She added that the Democrats might have been victorious in the same way had the Republicans exercised complete authority during the war. She also said that the landslide of votes given Republican candidates was greater than the expectations of the most sanguine members of the party. Mrs. Boyer declared that the change in political parties, the high prices existing and the wave of unemployment now starting to sweep the country, is a repetition of the aftermath of events of the Civil war. She expressed the hope though that the country will not have to combat the amount of crime caused by idleness, as in the days of Lincoln. Mrs. Boyer paid high compliment to Will I. Hays, Republican national chairmen, for his ability as an organizer. She also stated that the organization of the entire Republican party for the presidential election was the greatest in the history of any political organization. She said this was due to money which the Republican party had at its command and which was spent in every part of the country. The Democrats, she asserted, were handicapped for money, hence their organizing work fell far short of their plans. In Boston, Mrs. Boyer said, the Republican funds made possible a canvass of the entire city and paid for pamphlets of instruction to the new women voters. She stated that the state chairman of the Democratic committee in Massachusetts, when asked what he was going to do for the women voters, said he would not be able to do anything because of lack of money. Mrs. Boyer argued that women of the country should not place too much credence in the talk of extravagant expenditure of money in political campaigns. She explained that this was absolutely necessary to insure the best of organization, and to prove her contention she told of spending $7,000 for sending out only one letter to each woman in Oklahoma, when she tried to organize that state for woman and child legislation. Mrs. Boyer's lineup of the political parties in the elections just past were the Republican party, Anti-Saloon league and Non-Partisan league against the Democratic party and the American Federation of Labor. The speaker said the only scare thrown into the Republican camp during the campaign was caused when Samuel Gompers, president of the A. F. of L., promised to support the Democrats. After stating that the Anti-Saloon league is one of the most wholehearted organizations for good in the country, Mrs. Boyer explained the inception of the Non-Partisan league. This party, she said, is strong in only a few Western states and is composed mostly of farmers. The latter, she said, angered by getting only $2.59 a bushel for wheat for which they were promised $3 during war time, and selling wool and hides at a loss, blamed the administration at Washington. They couldn't see, Mrs. Boyer said, that a remedy for their losses could be brought about by cooperative marketing and a study of economic conditions, but decided that the Democrats were the cause of their misfortune. Hence, she stated, the league turned against this party and supported the Republican party. Mrs. Boyer expressed the opinion that no political party will ever have the huge problems to face such as face the Republicans during the next four years. Continuing along this topic she said: "If the party does well and succeeds in bringing about normal conditions again, I look for the Republicans to be one big power for many years to come. But if they fail, they will probably suffer worse defeat than the Democratic party did in November of this year." A league or association of nations is not needed simply to prevent war, according to Mrs. Boyer. She told the club members that it is rather demanded for commercial reasons. She explained that his country cannot hope to prosper by keeping apart from the rest of the world, and that trade with Germany must soon be resumed. England, she said, became wise to this fact some time ago and Germany's war debt is being paid England regularly by shipments of dyestuffs. Mrs. Boyer prophesied that one of President Harding's first acts will be the calling of the senate to discuss renewal of relations with all foreign countries. Relief from taxation and general reorganization of the country's resources will be the big work for the Republican administration to accomplish, Mrs. Boyer said. "There is going to be much unemployment throughout the country shortly," she added in discussing taxation, "and unless something is done to solve the tax problem, it is going to go hard with these people. If the Republicans can bridge over these events, it will not be long before the country is once again on its feet." At the conclusion of the address, tea was served and a social hour enjoyed. consent of her husband, and this consent will probably not be forthcoming. Another case in point is that of a young woman from California who married a Frenchman. In her mother's will she was made the executor. On the death of her mother she put the will on file in California, when she was informed that aliens are forbidden to be executors. This decree threw the mother's property into the hands of the lawyers, which was exactly what the mother had wished to avoid. "In Canada the woman retains her birthright as also in England. Canada declares that the children of parents of different nationalities may choose, when they come of age, to which country they prefer to belong. There is now a bill in Congress asking that women may choose their nationality. "Regarding the naturalization of foreign women--if a citizen of the United States of a foreigner naturalized here should send for a bride and marries her at Ellis Island or within the three-mile limit the woman becomes a citizen of the United States. A man must be here five years before he can take out his last, or naturalization papers. His first or 'Declaration of Intention' papers he may take out on his arrival in this country. He may live here three years before he files his first papers, but in any case two years must elapse between the taking out of his first and last papers. There are seven states where 'first paper' men are permitted to vote. In many cases these men never intend to become full-fledged citizens. They take the preliminary steps only in order to avail themselves of the advantage thus afforded by the protection of the United States Government. It is disgraceful that a man who has never taken an oath for the United States flag should be allowed to vote! "The naturalization of the father makes the minor children citizens of the United States; those children who are of age at the time remain foreigners. The wife, who may perhaps still be in Italy, or in France, also becomes through the husband [?] naturalized an American citizen. If a man dies after taking out his first papers, the wife can step in and finish the process at the end of five years and the minor children then become United States citizens. Suppose an Italian becomes naturalized, and then marries a women who has three children. The step-father's naturalization papers naturalize the step- children. "This is a big subject. When we consider that fact that we have living with us in Massachusetts a population of which one-third is foreign adults, another third their foreign-born children, it certainly seems to be our duty to see that the strangers within our gates become good citizens." Mrs. Boyer will give the last lecture of this series on "Government" in the library next Wednesday at three o'clock, when she will speak on "Political Vocabulary-- The Meaning of Peculiar Terms [?] National and State Legislation." Every one is heartily welcome. The last lecture will undoubtedly be fully as instructive and entertaining as the first three. [*CS Monitor Mar. 30, 1922*] SUFFRAGE RIGHTS ARE URGED FOR WOMEN OF PHILIPPINES "They Are More Progressive Than Men," Mrs. Porter-Boyer Asserts, on Return From Orient Suffrage rights for the women of the Philippines are being urged by Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer, who has just returned from an extensive tour of the Orient where she has been studying the conditions of women. Mrs. Porter- Boyer has a nation-wide reputation for her suffrage work, having formerly been the editor of the "New Southern Citizen," the official organ of the Southern Suffrage Association. She is at present one of the directors of the Boston League of Women Voters. "Women of the Philippines are more progressive than the men, yet they are denied the vote. It is high time that the women who are the real economic powers in their islands be given a share in the Government," declared Mrs. Porter-Boyer, to a representative of the Christian Science Monitor. "Before the United States took over the Philippines, the women were acknowledged to be superior to the men as far as industry and ambition were concerned. They excelled in all the cottage industries, in agriculture, and in business, and were more receptive to education than the men of the islands. WOMAN'S HIGH POSITION "As in most tribal communities, the line of descent was through the mother and the property rights belonged to the woman. She owned the little nipa-cottages where the family lived, and she was the custodian of any money that came into the family coffers. When men were suddenly given the franchise which was denied her, she could not understand why. She has never been able to comprehend the logic of the distinction. And we who are acquainted with her and the men of her country are even less able to comprehend it. "The Philippines are certainly not ready for self-government. They have proved it by their incompetent financial management during the last two years. But there is every reason to be hopeful about their prospects for self-government very soon, because they manifest the most active interest in the public affairs of their country. Of the 1,200,000 qualified voters, 700,000 voted in the last election for the Legislature. That is a percentage that would put most of the cities of the United States to shame! "The people of the Philippines are education-hungry. When you consider that they have had only one generation of opportunity, the fact that the illiteracy rate is only 29 per cent is astonishing. That is 2 per cent better than two of our southern states Louisiana and New Mexico. OLDER THAN HARVARD "The chief difficulty in the public schools is in getting teachers who are adequately trained. The native teachers are handicapped because of their exceedingly bad pronunciation of English. There are only 550 teachers on the island, one-half of whom are American. Five thousand more are needed. But unless the United States is willing to advance $10,000,000 that the Philippines need, there is little likelihood that they will be secured. "The University of Manila is older than Harvard and is a coeducational institution of the highest standard. The new Normal School at Manila is finer than any we have in the United States. The Filipinos read a great deal and are keenly interested in all sorts of knowledge. They are like children who have discovered a wonderful fund of pleasure. "In the families of the peasants the women are usually the wage-earners. The men care for the children as naturally as women do in this country. You will find women engaged in business in the great markets while their husbands remain at home, watching the children and wearing occasionally. "Laundering in the Philippines is very much like dish washing in other countries. It happens several times a day, because the peasants have few clothes--indeed, only enough to wear all the time. This is because their huts, made from the tough nipa leaves, are too small to permit the maintenance of an extensive wardrobe. But in spite of their lack of clothes they are immaculate, taking great pride in their crisp, rice-starched garments. AMERICANS RESPECTED "The malicious rumors that always have been spread of the hatred of the Philippines for the United States Government is false. The very opposite is true. To be an American citizen is to have a passport to the best the islands have to offer. Americans are treated with the utmost respect, and the Filipinos feel a keen sense of hospitality toward them. "Filipino children are eager to learn English and their parents have the greatest trust in American customs and ways of doing things. 'We would like to be free,' they say, 'but we want the United States always to be our protector.' There is the most friendly feeling possible between the Filipino and American sections of the Government. They work together harmoniously and mutually realize that they are gradually working toward the independence of the Philippines in the most sane, advantageous manner. "Of the 13,000 office holders, only 500 are American, and the number is steadily decreasing. Under the Osmena Act providing a bonus for American office holders who will resign of their own accord, the government is literally being given into the hands of the Filipino people. "They understand as clearly as do Americans who have studied the situation that the time is not yet ripe for complete freedom, and they are not impatient. Agitation seethes, of course, in certain quarters, as it always does under any conditions in any country, but in the main there is contentment in the Philippines." Brookline Chronicle - April 20, 1920 FOURTH OF LECTURES FOR WOMEN VOTERS Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer Spoke on "Political Vocabulary" Wednesday The last of the four talks on "Government," arranged by the Brookline Equal Suffrage Association, was given in the Brookline Public Library on Wednesday afternoon by Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer, who took for her subject, "Political Vocabulary - The Meaning of Peculiar Terms in National and State Legislation." "We earnestly hope," said Mrs. Robert H. Schacht before introducing the speaker, "that this audience will tell other women about the lessons learned here and pass the word along, thus acting as a bit of leaven in the production of good citizenship. Tell about registering and voting and constructive legislation and, by putting it on a higher plane, perform the duty of voting, as Mrs. Boyer suggested in her last lecture, in the spirit of making a sacrament." Mrs. Boyer gave, as usual, an interesting discourse and spoke in effect as follows: "When Mrs. Schacht suggests, that 'we pass the word along,' it reminds me of a lady who attended a series of lectures of mine at a club in Reading. She repeated, in substance, what she had heard to her husband, who became so impressed with the idea of women taking an interest in and really studying Government and Legislation that he now wishes to arrange for a similar course of lectures to be given for his employees. It is a great act of civic patriotism when me have appreciation of the work we are doing. We will now take up the terms which are more or less peculiar to our legislation." Mrs. Boyer then enumerated a number of these terms, some of which she explained. "The first idea of Direct Legislation is that it shall be wholly representative and this is done when a representative, elected by the people, is sent to the legislature. The law once was what the legislators should elect. Direct Legislation means that the people vote for something without going through the legislators, so that each voter directly expresses himself and may thus initiate or start a movement. [?????????????????????] as he pleases. The term caucus arose in Massachusetts. Every time a vessel docked her seams required caulking. This brought to the docks large numbers of caulkers, whose strength became sufficient to admit of forming a kind of union which frequently held secret meetings, when it was said, 'The caulkers are meeting,' and thence was derived the term caucus. "There are fixed tariff rates. Reciprocity means the reciprocal action of two countries or two states, as when Canada, foreseeing that her wool crop will be very large, whereas that in Wyoming and Iowa may be small, says to the United States, 'If you will allow my wool (Continued on Page Fourteen) FOURTH OF LECTURES FOR WOMEN VOTERS (Continued from Page Eleven) in on a low or no tariff, I will permit entrance to one of your goods on the same basis.' "The Injunction and Abatement Act applies wholly to houses of prostitution. Some states allow licenses, which protect the owners of the houses. New Orleans, Denver, and San Francisco thought a 'Red Light District' necessary, but after the youth of one generation had been debauched all three cities nullified the prostitution licenses. This law serves as a protection to the neighborhood, so that if a house of ill fame becomes a nuisance any one may take out an injunction against it. The 'Tin-plate' law serves somewhat as a deterrent in New York, where after the 'Red Light District' was annulled licenses for separate houses continued to be taken out. This law means that if 'Mrs. John Smith' leases a house to 'Mrs. Thomas Brown' knowing that it will be used for prostitution purposes, the former's name is put on that door. When Vincent Astor learned that his property was used for such purposes he declared that his name should not be tacked on houses of prostitution and he got rid of his property. This law is effectually enforced. "In 1891 Senator Sherman introduced the Anti-trust Act which states that any monopoly in restraint of trade is illegal. The large combinations of great trust interests began in the 1880's and small producers began to find themselves crowded out and either succumbed or joined the big interests. The Standard Oil Company agreed to dissolve, but established minor concerns in different states under various state laws, thus virtually maintaining its control "The Homestead Act came into effect with the throwing open of parcels of Government land and a stay of five years on the land entitled a claimant to ownership. The improvement of the property, as fencing, building, etc., sometimes amounting to $100 or more, however, was in many cases prohibitive and resulted in the return of the land to the Government. Farms in New England and elsewhere were more easily taken up. "The Interstate Law means the exchange of goods between states. Mississippi has loose Child Labor laws, and thus produces a little faster many of the same things made in Louisiana where the Child Labor Law is stringent. The Intra-State Law permits Mississippi to sell these goods within her own state, but the Inter-State law forbids her to dispose of them in Louisiana. "Irrigation and Reclamation have converted many unproductive portions of our country. In the Northwestern section of the States where some tremendous convulsion of nature in the past deposited a vast amount of lava, irrigation makes the soil produce and no soil equals that of lava in fertility. Oregon, Idaho, and Washington have utilized water distribution to such an extent that land is often not purchasable at $15,000 an acre. "Next we have under consideration the Franking System and Leave to Print. The Franking System permits the use of the mails free, and this privilege is allowed to only two women: Mrs. Cleveland, now Mrs. Preston, and Mrs. Roosevelt. It is a custom much abused. I have seen a quarter of a million documents franked into one state, and we pay for all that. A certain congressman sent a telegram seven feet long about some wonderful thing that he had done. Leave to print was originally innocent and admirable, but is now abused by congressmens who desire to impress their constituents. John Doe who cannot make a speech employs someone to write one for him in, say, the Mother's Pension bill. He asks the Speaker of the House to have his speech incorporated in the proceedings of the day. This is called Leave to Print. Then he has his speech printed in the Congressional Record, and not satisfied with this he has four thousand or so copies sent to his constituents. He is thus campaigning at our expense. Read 'The Searchlight' to find specific instances of these things. It is time for us to abrocate Leave to Print. The same should be done with the Franking System. These things are so common that we accept them without thinking. I have a high opinion of most of the men in public life. A man finds a hopeless condition confronting him and when he does his best we should tell him. Be sure that no man goes to Congress because of personal ambition and with no idea of service. "Nearly every bill passes through by Log Rolling. This means that a congressman may agree to help get votes for measure another man may be trying to get through, if the second man will promise to assist him with his own bill. In some cases there is nothing wrong in it; in others this method is used for illegitimate purposes. "Ratification of a Constitutional amendment is attained when three-fourths of the states ratify. Thus thirty six "Yes" make it a part of the Constitution. "Immediately after the Civil War, the Southern States revised their Constitution and employed various devices for eliminating the black man from the electorate. One of these was the Grandfather Law which, in Oklahoma and Maryland, ruled that: 'If your ancestors were eligible to vote prior to 1860 you inherit that right.' The negroes tested this law, and it was pronounced invalid in those states. Mississippi had this law, but did not bother much about it. She emphasized the educational qualification, which in operation meant that one might be illiterate but if, white, managed to waive the educational qualification; while one might be college bred but, if black, was not allowed to vote. A certain well-known, finely educated doctor, a colored man, applied for registration. The clerk looked through his books and read aloud: 'Question No. 42. What came next?' The doctor could not answer. 'White Primaries' was sometimes placed over the doorway, thus effectually barring out the negro. There were no black primaries. In Alabama the Cumulative Poll Tax was used for eliminating undesired voters. When you applied for registration, if you had not paid the poll taxes for 1917, 1918, and 1919, if they wanted your vote, you would be told that payment of the tax for 1920 alone would be sufficient; if, however you were not desired as a voter the poll taxes of all those years would be demanded and inability to pay them might throw you out. There has been discrimination all along the line against the black man." After the lecture many of those present thanked Mrs. Boyer for her interesting talks. THE FOREMOTHERS OF NEW ENGLAND DRAMATIC PICTURES PORTRAYING WOMAN'S CONTRIBUTION TO THE HISTORY OF NEW ENGLAND FORD HALL, ASHBURTON PLACE FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 25, 1921, 8 O'CLOCK TICKETS $1.00, $1.50, $2.00 (ALL SEATS RESERVED) FOOD SALE KINGSLEY HALL, FORD BUILDING, 11 A.M. TO 7 P.M. LUNCHEON 12 TO 2 AFTERNOON TEA 3 TO 5 SUPPER 5 TO 7 BOSTON LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS, 553 LITTLE BUILDING, BOSTON PATRONESSES Mrs. John K. Allen Mrs. Oakes Ames Mrs. Julius Andrews Miss Sarah Louise Arnold Mrs. George Minot Baker Miss Mable M. Barkley Mrs. John W. Bartol Mrs. Charles Sumner Bird Miss Alice Stone Blackwell Mrs. Charles H. Bond Mrs. Richard C. Cabot Mrs. David Cheever Mrs. George W. Coleman Mrs. Channing H. Cox Miss Mary Caroline Crawford Mrs. Courtenay Crocker Mrs. Eugene A. Crockett Mrs. Francis B. Crowninshield Mrs. Robert Culbert Mrs. Charles K. Cummings Mrs. Edward Cummings Mrs. Charles G. Cunningham Miss Hester Cunningham Miss Francis G. Curtis Mrs. Thomas P. Curtis Miss Alice Dabney Mrs. Tucker Daland Mrs. Bancroft G. Davis Mrs. George B. Dewson Miss Rose L. Dexter Mrs. David Dunbar Mrs. H. Boyd Edwards Mrs. Julius Eiseman Miss Margaret Elder Mrs. George R. Fearing, Jr. The Misses Flint Mrs. Allan Forbes Mrs. J. Malcolm Forbes Miss Eugeaia B. Frothingham Mrs. Langdon Frothingham Mrs. Louis A. Frothingham Mrs. Alvan T. Fuller Mrs. Francis P. Garland Mrs. Robert Grant Mrs. Horace Gray Mrs. Charles E. Guild, Jr. Mrs. N. P. Hallowell Mrs. J. Mott Hallowell Mrs. Robert H. Hallowell Mrs. Augustus Hemenway Mrs. Roland G. Hopkins Miss Louvan W. Hyde Mrs. Lewis Jerome Johnson Mrs. Stanley King Mrs. F. L. Kershaw Mrs. Louis Kirstein Mrs. Felix Kornfeld Miss Rose Lamb Mrs. Amory A. Lawrence Miss Sarah Lawrence Mrs. John C. Lee Mrs. Gustaf Lundberg Mrs. Mary Agnes Mahan Miss Ellen Mason Mrs. Samuel W. McCall Mrs. Lucia Ames Mead Mrs. Arthur W. Moors Mrs. John F. Moors Mrs. Robert Lincoln O'Brien Miss Fanny C. Osgood Mrs. Charles Peabody Mrs. Harold Peabody Mrs. Andrew J. Peters Mrs. Louis Rosenthal Mrs. Benjamin F. Pitman Miss Katherine McD. Rice Mrs. E.S. Rousmaniere Mrs. Henry E. Russell Mrs. James S. Russell Mrs. Francis B. Sayre Miss Annie L. Sears Miss Mary P. Sears Mrs. Robert Gould Shaw Mrs. Fred L. Smith Mrs. Alexander Steinert Mrs. George H. Stoddard Mrs. A.W. Tedeastle Mrs. Alden Thorndike Mrs. James R. Torbert Mrs. George C. Warren Mrs. Royal Whiton Mrs. Robert A. Woods DEDICATORY Foremother, at thy glowing shrine Thy daughters strive to give thee meed. With ardor scan between each line Of History's page, for word and deed. You self-less wrought as woman's part The heroism of the age. Thy mother-hand and mother -heart Prompt to accept stern Fortune's guage. No glittering Fame impelled thy way Nor chance in Battle's spoil; Thy hearth-defence thy task each day, By Faith and Love and Toil. Like beads upon the string of Time Thy varied acts unnumbered, grace; In iridescent softness shine With gem-like value to the race. You wove the cloth with fervid will For Freedom's robe, in darksome hour; And if perchance some 'broidered skill Its fold adorned, 'twas beauty's dower. Dear Mother of the long-sped days In cape, or ruff, or gay brocade,- A reverent paean in thy praise Thy daughters have this tribute made. IDA PORTER-BOYER. Brookline Mass The Chronicle Mar 20, 1920 OPEN LECTURE COURSE FOR WOMEN VOTERS Mrs. Porter-Boyer Gives Instructive Talk on "Our "Government" The first of a series of four talks on "Government" by Mrs. Ida Porter- Boyer, arranged by the Brookline Equal Suffrage Association, was given on Wednesday afternoon in the lecture hall of the Brookline Public Library. The subject for that afternoon was: "Our Nation -- Its First Steps." Mrs. Robert H. Schacht presided and before introducing the speaker she explained that since the work for suffrage is over, the Brookline Equal Suffrage Association is making the educational policy its object. Mrs. Schacht introduced Mrs. Boyer as an active member of the State Suffrage Association and said that she had been assisting in the Western Campaign for the Federal Amendment. Mrs. Boyer spoke with much charm and delightful humor and gave an extremely interesting and clear exposition of the beginnings of our government, prefacing her talk by expressing her wish that the women might henceforth eliminate "all suffrage and anti tags," and work harmoniously together for beneficent laws and better living conditions. "In the early days of the Massachusetts Colony," said Mrs. Boyer, in substance, "the first action taken toward establishing male suffrage was in the giving of voting privileges to male members in good standing in the Congregational Church, which privileges were later extended to other churches. Next it was considered advisable to admit men holding property, or rich men, which property limitation was withdrawn in 1824 and those now owning land, etc., were allowed to vote. After the Civil War the black men were admitted to the polls. The next extension included the red men, when the territory of Oklahoma, with which Indian Territory had been incorporated, applied for statehood in order that the Indians within her boundaries might become enfranchised and thereby enabled to dispose legally to the white men the rich lands they so much coveted. "The first step forward in political freedom for women was taken in 1838 when Kentucky gave the school vote to women with children and from that time to the present the onward march of women suffrage has been rapid. "The history of the National Government began ten years before the Revolution. A Massachusetts man, Samuel Adams, was the first one to forsee the break with the mother country, for England, with her policy of deriving all possible revenue from her colonies, imposed insufferable taxation upon everything. At this time Samuel Adams was the moving power in this country. Although our ancestors came to the continent seeking liberty of conscience, they in their turn followed narrow-minded policies, as is seen in their persecutions of the so-called Salem witches, etc. From this followed a reaction which resulted in the establishment of the Unitarian Church Massachusetts later proved her increasing liberal views when she became the first state to send a company of soldiers to fight in behalf of the negroes. "Our National Legislature consists of a Congress formed by two houses and known as the Bi-Cameral system. In this are three departments, the Legislative, the Executive, and the Judicial. The thirteen states operated under their own charters which were guarded with zealous care, a famous instance of this being the historic Charter Oak of Connecticut. When the Nation was formed, the idea was to have a Central government to which each of the thirteen states was to delegate some of its powers, such as raising an army, the imposing of taxes, etc. "At the Capitol at Washington the Legislative body consists of the Senate and the House of Representatives. United States Senators, of whom there are 96, must be thirty-five years or older before they can be elected, their term being six years. The Senate is a self-continuing body, as at the end of a session of Congress only on third of its members find their term expired. The members of the House of Representatives whom there are 435, are elected for two years so that the members change every two years. A candidate for the House must be Twenty- five years old before he can be elected to the house. Every state has the same number of senators, that is two, but the House membership is based on population one representative being allowed to 211,877 inhabitants. Massachusetts has sixteen representatives. "The President appoints the members of his Cabinet, which appointments are confirmed by Congress. In case of the death of the President, he is succeeded by the Vice-President and should both of these expire through some extraordinary cause, such as an epidemic, the successor is chosen from the members of the Cabinet in order of their rank. The Supreme Court consists of nine men who are the Supreme Court Justices of the United States and can be removed only for malfeasance in office. This rule gives them freedom to make decisions without fear of removal on account of disatisfaction with their ruling." The next lecture will be given at the Brookline Public Library next Wednesday afternoon at three o'clock, when Mr. Boyer's subject will be "Political Parties- Past and Present." A cordial invitation to attend this interesting free course is extended to everyone. MME. MALMBERG DIES IN FINLAND Author, Pacifist and Patriot Was Exiled by Russians Before World War. Times OFTEN LECTURED IN THE U.S. 2-26-33 Translated Bernard Shaw's Works Into Finnish - Member of Ford's Peace Ship Party. Mme. Aino Malmberg of Finland, author, pacifist, feminist and patriot, who before the down fall of the Czar aided in the struggle for Finnish freedom and helped Russian revolutionists, died on Feb. 3 in Helsingfors of heart disease, according to word received by friends in this country. Her age was 67. Arrested by the Russian police in 1910 and exiled, Mme. Malmberg for twenty years maintained a small apartment in London, which became a centre for the exponents of the rights of small nations. She never was able to learn why she was arrested and exiled. Mme. Malmberg knew many of the terrorists of the Czarist days, and was bitter against the cruelty of the imperal spy system. "The terrorists," she said in a lecture here in 1913, "are not necessarily bloodthirsty revolutionists. For the most part they are dreamers, poets, young men who foolishly believe that the only salvation is to kill some one to show that the people won't submit to wrongs. These men are not by nature cruel." She assailed the massacres of Jews as the result of incitation by the secret police, who told lies about the Jews to inflame the populace. Mme. Malmberg came to this country most often in the period between 1912 and 1918, lecturing on Finnish literature and pleading the cause of Finnish freedom. A pacifist in the World War, she came to know Miss Jane Addams, Mme. Rosicka Schwimmer and other leading anti-militarists. Henry Ford Peace Ship expedition in 1916, and acted as the official Scandinavian translator for the group and editor of the daily bulletin in English. Two of her sons fought against Russia in the war, and when Finland became independent after the war, served as Finnish soldiers. the eldest, Lauri, a mathematician, is now a Major General and Commander of the National Civic Guard. The first class of women to enter the University of Helsingfors when it opened its doors to women about 1883 included Mme. Malmberg. She later became official translator of Bernard Shaw's works into Finnish. Although her political activity interrupted her literary career for years, she was the author of many articles in the Finnish, British and American press and of two volumes of sketches of persons she had met. One, called "People of Power," dealt with the great she had known, and the other, "The Powerless Ones," with unknown and simple heroes. She also wrote an Australian travel book which brought about a migration of Finns to Australia in 1929-30, when American immigration laws became more stringent. An ardent worker for women's suffrage, Mme. Malberg said in 1913 that there were no anti-suffragists in Finland. She pointed out that suffrage had been granted alike to men and women more than 24 years of age. N.Y. Times 1/29/33 SELMA LAGERLOF HEARD. Swedish Novelist, on Radio, Urges Us to Lead World Efforts. A plea for American leadership in the current efforts to deal with world problems was voiced yesterday by Selma Lagerlof. Swedish novelist and Nobel Prize winner, in an address delivered at Stockholm and transmitted to this country by the National Broadcasting Company. Dr. Lagerlof recalled the inventions that have gone to Europe from the United States, including the typewriter, mowing machine, self-binder, electric lights, motor cars, phonograps and the cinema. Sweden, in particular, had received help from two movements prominent in America, she declared, that for the emancipation of women and that for temperance. She praised American efforts to combat disease and also American relief work. WOMEN HOMESTEADERS CANADIAN women in considerable numbers are answering the call of the land. A change in the regulations governing the acquisition of homesteads has sent more than 2,000 Alberta women into the venture in eighteen months. Formerly, only widows who were heads of families were eligible along with men; now any woman of age and certain residential qualifications may take up a homestead in Alberta. CHILEAN WOMEN ASK VOTE. 2-14-33 Fill Galleries of Congress in Suffrage Demonstration. Special Cable to THE NEW YORK TIMES. SANTIAGO, Chile, Feb. 13.- Filling the Congressional galleries, including the aisles, thousands of Chilean women today demanded the right to vote in municipal elections. The energetic speeches made by the leaders of the women reveal the extent of the movement, which is looked upon favorably by a majority of the Deputies. Gabriel Gonzales, the President of the Chamber, asserted the women of Chile should receive suffrage with the same rights as men. Women Required To Cast Ballot In Roumania 2-11-33 Special to The Christian Science Monitor BUCHAREST, Roumania--Women in Roumania are obliged to vote. It is compulsory for all those who qualify - but qualifying is not so easy. An appeal has just been sent out to the women of Roumania by Mme. Elena C. Meissner, President of the "Association for the Emancipation of Civil and Political Rights of Roumanian Women." The appeal notifies women of the risk they run in neglecting to register themselves as voters the moment they qualify and urges them to lose no time in aligning themselves with the organization working for their freedom. The qualifying conditions for the woman voter demand that the voter must be at least 21 years of age and must have finished at least the inferior secondary school, normal school or professional school. She must be employed by the state or a commune as a functionary, or have been decorated for activity during the war, or have taken part in the formation or direction of a society recognized by the state, for the purpose of combating social evils, giving social assistance or making cultural propaganda, or be a war widow. WOMEN WELCOME BRYAN'S STATEMENT ON THE SUFFRAGE 1914 New Orleans Leaders Say He Sees the Handwriting on the Wall Whether William Jennings Bryan's declaration in favor of suffrage was due to a wonderful vision or to political acumen matters very little to the suffragists, according to the view expressed Friday by some of the leaders of the woman movement. Miss Jean Gordon, State president of the Louisiana State Suffrage Association, said she was delighted that Mr. Bryan had come to so positive a conclusion regarding woman suffrage. "We wrote him five or six years ago to express himself relative to this issue, but Mr. Bryan replied to us that he had not studied the subject sufficiently to make a statement. I think five or six years' reflection should indicate a mastery of the subject, and Mr. Bryan's conclusion should be of great value." Miss Gordon stated with evident amusement. "If Mr. Bryan with all of is other duties sees the value of enfranchising the women, I think others might see something in it, too. Mr. Roosevelt of the Progressive party openly declared in favor of women voting, and others, too, are beginning to see the value of this stand, I suppose. Mr. Bryan's expressions are very timely, and I am glad he gave them. This fall his State (Nebraska) will vote on the issue, and, doubtless, his declaration will wield a wide influence there. I am very much pleased that Mr. Bryan is with us." concluded Miss Jean Gordon. WELCOMED REGARDLESS OF MOTIVE Mrs. Ida Porter Boyer, the executive secretary of the Southern States Woman's Suffrage Conference, also said that Mr. Bryan's acknowledged sympathy with suffrage was just in time to influence Nebraska. "Mr. Wilson has placed himself on record as opposing suffrage, and, unless it should be a plank of the Democratic platform, that he could not support it as a Democratic President. Well, two things are significant, I think. Champ Clark, the Speaker of the House, from yearning desire, might be a candidate for the Presidency some day, and who knows but that Bryan may be a candidate, too, from force of habit. Both of these men have declared for suffrage. The people of Missouri also vote on the issue in November. Whatever might be said, we are pleased that both Mr. Bryan and Mr. Clark have declared for suffrage before the vote is taken in their States, and this is going to help the cause very much. We have ten States, and the chances are that Missouri and Nebraska will be added in November. Then the two Dakotas are about ready, and Nevada will, doubtless, be added about the same time. Now it seems to me that he who runs may read. If all of these States, the ten acquired and the five possible ones, should allow women to vote, about 6,000,000 women would be casting the ballot for the man who most represents their views. Whatever the motive, let us accept the fact that Bryan's declaration is in our favor, and rejoice accordingly." Mrs. Boyer said. Mrs. Edgar Cahn, the president of the Woman's Suffrage party in Louisiana, seemed very much pleased over the telegraphic announcement. "It is just that Mr. Bryan has seen the handwriting on the wall. that is the only interpretation that can be placed on his statement. The Suffrage party is rejoiced at every partial victory from any source. Just as Mr. Bryan has seen the inevitable and met it half way, just as surely do we read between the lines of his 'declaration,' and we know that he feels that suffrage may yet be a feather in the cap of William Jennings Bryan. We women cannot view the announcement otherwise, and it makes me realize that suffrage is coming on apace, and that it may be here before we have to do much more agitating. As to the men of our own State," continued Mrs. Cahn, "they will give the women the ballot, I feel positive. Our men are sympathetic and if appealed to in the right way and the issue presented fortunately, it will not be long before we will have suffrage, like the ten other States already victorious. Bryan's declaration is a good omen, a weathervane of hope." SUFFRAGE COMING FAST. Miss Florence Loeber declared suffrage was coming very fast, and that she was not surprised to read of Mr. Bryan's announcement. "Why, men of national vision like Champ Clark and Bryan know they cannot afford to take any other stand, especially when their political careers are not yet over. Who knows, they, like Caeser, may be 'ambitious,' and this announcement may bring them support from several million women in their future political careers. The news is very encouraging and very significant."' Presidency influence the men of our own State. The Era Club, that pioneer in the suffrage work of this State, has done the subsoil plowing for eighteen years, and the planting of the seed, and it should be time for the harvest. The Era Club is not the only suffrage organization now in the State, and all of these influences should help us attain the desired end. I am very much gratified that Mr. Bryan has helped us along, directly or indirectly, and I hope the women of Louisiana will be given the franchise before the end of two years. Then I hope to see them turn the energy they are now expending in behalf of suffrage to constructive work with the power of the ballot behind them." THE ANDALUSIA STAR (Semi-Weekly) CHANCE FOR SUFFRAGETS. In Andalusia school district alone there are 163 white children of school age who can neither read nor write. Here's a golden opportunity for suffragets to get busy and do some practical work for the betterment of government. Sure! And it's a golden opportunity for social and literary clubs to revolutionize things over the county. Why store up more education and more comfort for ourselves when those at our very doors are unable to read the Bible - foundation upon which our hopes are built here and hereafter? Never mind about votes for women. There's a greater and grander opportunity. Just think how a few good women could change things by teaching these 163 hopeless, helpless humans to read and write during spare moments. Cut amusements and social calls in two in the middle. Cut out about half of the bridge, dominoes, etc., and give these hours to the unfortunate white children who can neither read or write. If you can't go to the children's homes bring them to your homes. Any way to give them a start. This is a sort of education that ought to be compulsory. Women know how to go about it kindly. Every white child should know how to read and write. If we can teach that much we've laid the foundation for better government. -Andalusia Star. New Orleans, La., September 2, 1914 Edward Doty, Editor, Andalusia Star, Andalusia, Ala. My dear Mr. Doty: Thank you for the clipping sent us in reference to the illiteracy and the lack of opportunity among the white children of the South. This question is one of the many wherein women can affect a great change. To the shame of Alabama as well as other Southern States, women are not admitted to school elections nor permitted to serve on School Boards, and have no direct power to affect legislation, compulsory or otherwise, regarding the education of the youth of the State. The education of children sould pre-eminently be within the mother's power, but since in Alabama and other Southern States no mother has a voice in the Public School control, the stigma of illiteracy of a State now rests upon the men who have failed to better conditions. Personally I think this is an unjust burden to place wholly upon our men and I am amazed that men have not long ago required women's aid in all that affects the public life of the child. The education of children by the State requires a system far reaching and compulsory so that no child, (the future asset of the State,) shall be deprived of the means of development into educated citizenship. Sporadic attempts by a few charitably inclined women will not solve the problem of illiteracy and would perhaps serve in some cases to place the individual child under personal obligation. The democracy of our Public Schools is a valuable training for politicial democracy. Consciencious fathers and mothers on School Boards would be a co-operative influence of immense benefit to the family in the State. I agree most heartily with you in your suggestion that women "cut out bridge, dominoes, etc.," and earnestly hope they will soon be given a chance in Alabama to employ the time thus gained by participating in the moral and political up-lift of their respective communities. Cordially yours, IDA PORTER-BOYER Secretary Southern States Woman Suffrage Conference. THE STATE: COLUMBIA, S.C., JANUARY 14, 1916 PREDICT WOMEN WILL VOTE SOON Time is Limited to Ten Years. CALLS ON THE SOUTH Mrs. Ida Porter Boyer of New Orleans Delivers Suffrage Lecture at Court House. Mrs. Ida Porter Boyer of New Orleans, a quiet, earnest little Southern gentlewoman with a natural manner, a sweet voice and a delightful sense of humor, gave a lecture on equal suffrage last evening before the Columbia Suffrage league at its monthly meeting. Dr. Jane Bruce Guignard, president of the league, introduced Mrs. Harriet Powe Lynch of Cheraw, president of State league, who spoke a few words of encouragement and confidence in regard to the attainment of suffrage by women in this State. "It is coming," declared she with conviction, prophesying that the delay will not be nearly the lapse of ten years as some people think it may be. Formerly Club Woman. Mrs. Lynch presented Mrs. Boyer as a woman first known as a club woman. "It is from the club women that we suffragists were evolved," she said. "As club women striving for certain reforms and improvements, we thought we could attain them for the asking; when we found we could not we turned suffrage advocates in order to have the power to bring these things about." Mrs. Boyer, disagreeing with the oft repeated opinion that while it may be all right for other parts of the country to take up the suffrage movement "it's different in the South," declared that she finds the bright, brainy women of all sections very much alike and said that it was a Southern woman, Mrs. Margaret Rhett of Marland, who first demanded the ballot. This as early as 1680. She then proceeded to review history to show that all men have not always voted. "We are apt to think that the right is purely a masculine one," said she, "and that a man has always voted simply because he was a man, whereas the vote came gradually." The voting privilege was originally founded on property rights. Then one by one the States eliminated the property qualification until now only one- Rhode Island- retains it. Originally the voting privilege was by no means limited to men. Women who held property were able to vote and the women of New Jersey did vote until 1807. The Inadvertent "Male." "When the constitution of the United States was written there was no idea of excluding the women," she pointed out. "We, the people of the United States,' reads the preamble, and the word 'male' was not put in until we put it with the 14th and 15th amendments." Later she explained that the federal bill now pending, known as the United States elections bill, is to ask congress to "revitalize" this part of the constitution. It is not an amendment to the constitution, it is simply a bill to enable women to vote for congressmen and senators. "My own hopes lie in the South," declared Mrs. Boyer. "We have not the awful problems to solve here that they have in some of the Northern States where the population is migratory and therefore hard to educate to the ideals of democracy. Here in the South we have the purest type of democratic people. "I am confident that the Southern men will translate their chivalry into justice," said she, after reviewing the movement in the South and mentioning the States that have had suffrage bills up before their legislatures." Men and the Ballot. In eloquent comment on the statement that men are fond of making, to the effect that "when all the women want the ballot we will let them have it," the speaker cited the truth that no class, race or band of men has ever had to ask for the ballot; it has always been presented to them without solicitation in some cases even thrust upon them. One of the most convincing features of Mrs. Boyer's address was her account of the actual "working" of equal suffrage in the Western States, in two of which - Wyoming and Colorado- she has spent much time with her two sisters who live in these States, respectively. She also told a number of stories to show how women in the suffrage States use their power of the ballot. "I think it is a splendid argument for equal suffrage that women will place principle above partisanship," declared she. In Wyoming, the first suffrage State, two generations have been educated by the women's ballot, for the school problem has always been turned over to the women and Wyoming has never had anything but a woman as State superintendent of education. Mrs. Boyer, in the course of her talk, in which she held her audience attentively interested for an hour and a half, paid tribute to Mrs. Virginia D. Young of Fairfax, whom she knew personally. ATTANOOGA NEWS MONDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 1914 TO DISCUSS CLAIMS OF BOTH SECTIONS Work of Conference of Equal Suffrage Leaders. Twenty-eight Countries Now Awaiting Outcome. Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer and Miss Caroline Reilly, Representatives, Seen in Interview. The significance of the present conference of the Southern States Equal Suffrage association, which begins Tuesday at the Hotten Petten, is of greater moment than may upon the surface appear. What is bringing together the leaders of the section and placing them in intimate communication with those of the north in Chattanooga, the gateway between the two, is a matter which concerns the suffragists of twenty-eight different countries. All eyes are fixed upon Chattanooga at the present juncture, and the event has assumed historic importance. The grave question of the states' rights vs. nationalism is to be thrashed out. And get the leaders over the issue which made the men of an earlier day fly at each other's throats is to be settled in quiet conference of chairmen, northern and southern. The two representatives of opposing interests are the Gordon sisters of New Orleans, and Mrs. O. H. P. Belmont, of New York. The representatives and vanguard are, respectively, Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer and Miss carolint Reilly, press agents. A News representative sought the duo at the Hotel Patten last night and found them dining together. In compant with Miss Margaret Ervin, president of the local equal suffrage association, and Miss Catherine J. Wester of the national electionc ommitte, both presented the claims of the cause for which they stand-whether or not the enfranchisement of women shall be first introduced by the individial states separately, or by national constitutional amendment. The former will control the complexion of the franchise and the latter grant it indiscriminately, regardless of racial distinction. All of the merits and demerits of the Haynes-WEbster controversy were involved last night, and while no arguments were presented during the interview, each seemed in receptive mental attitude for listening to the statements of the other. The "logical male mind" might have learned lessons of value from the "emotional feminine mind"-to use Dr. Anna Shaw's differentiation. "Of course, we have rather opposed each other," said one of them, "but we have always done so in a friendly spirit of co-operation and we propose to continue it." "Was not the question of states' rights quietly disposed of in the western states granting equal suffrage?" was asked. "They had no problem such as confronts you to contend with," explained Miss Reilly. "In California, of course, where the presence of certain oriental women was inimical to the franchis, California women claimed the right of elimination. What we are trying to do is to get also into the viewpoint of the southerner." "Then," Mrs. Boyer was asked, "your idea, is it not, is to establish the white primary in those states where southern men have done so?" "Exactly," she replied. "We desire the same rights with our men voters. Where the grandfather clause is needed to preserve white supremacy we ask the privilege of obsercing the same, and for this reason we are opposing a national constitutional amendment." Each heard the other without comment, and the converstation drifted naturally to the status of equal suffrage in New York and Louisiana. "We do not feel that the question is quite as livelu as it should be in the south, since it has ceased to be national and is now a worldwide issue," observed norther Miss Riley. "Newspapers do not give it sufficient notoriety and space. Besides, every day in New York there are many open-air meetings throughout the length and breadth of the city. "But to show you just how wide is the interest in the state at large, let me tell you what was recently done in convention in New York. You know, before the suffrage question can be submitted to a vote of the people there it must be passed upon favorable by two sessions of legislature. It has already passed one. We were sitting in convention at Rochester and desired to raise a $50,000 campaign fund for the second passage. It was not only raised in a very few minutes, but we found that the same had been done in two other sections of the state, so that when the fund was amassed we had $150,000. We thought the war had interfered with public interest, but this proves to the contrary. "Vastly different," exclaimed Miss Boyer, "from the time we held convention during the Spanish-American war. We were in session at Washington. The papers had given us flaming headlines. Then the Maine blew up-and they forgot all about us." "Yes, war has always been the band of woman suffrage," observed Miss Wester. "I told a man recently," said Miss Ervin, "that if we women had been consulted, there would be no Belgian problem, because there would have been no war." Asked concerning the progress of equal suffrage in Louisiana, Mrs. Boyer gave an interesting resume of the work of the Era club (which, by the way, means E-qual R-ights A-ssociation), and she told how a recent seeming defeat was in reality a victory, since it preserved the factory inspectorship-the great activity of Miss Jean Gordon. She said that people are looking to the Era club for promulgation of the most reforms because New Orleans owes to Miss Gordon a debt of gratitude for working for the passage of so many bills giving the city certain commodities and needed restrictions. The sewerage system, factory inspectorship, park improvement, prohibiting racetrack gambling are but a few of these. That equal suffrage should have attained its present high standing in Louisiana, the most conservative state in the south, still adhering to the Napoleonic code in the legal consideration of womanhood, is, she thinks, finely significant. Events in Tennessee relating to the progress of the cause throughout the state were listening to with much interest by the two, as Miss Ervin and Miss Wester presented them. The conference this week precedes the national convention, which will open in Nashville, Recognition of one of the two factions of the state organization will be among items of particular interest to suffragists of Tennessee. Mrs. O. H. P. Belmont, however, who arrives tonight in her private car from New York, will not attend the state convention, but will return eat after the conference with Miss Reilly and Miss Christabel Pankhurst. Among prominent suffragists who will attend the conference are: Mrs. Medill McCormick, of Chicago; the Misses Gordon, of New Orleans; Mrs. Ernest Thompson Seton, who left yesterday for Nashville, but will return; Dorothy Dix, Mrs. Wesley Stoner, Miss Laura Clay, Ruth McEnery Stuart, Mrs. Katherine Waugh McCullough. Miss Kate Gordon will call the conference Tuesday morning at the Hotel Patten. In the evening a banquet will be held at the Hotel Patten. Tuesday and Wednesday nights the sessions will be held in the Lyric theater, when Mrs. O. H. P. Belmont and Miss Christabel Pankhurst will speak. DISTINGUISHED WOMEN OF SOUTH Delegates Arrive for the Suf- frage Conference. Business Sessions in Assembly- room of Hotel Patten--Lec- tures at Lyric. The program of the conference Tuesday will be as follows: MORNING 10:30--HOTEL PATTEN Convention called to order by the president--Kate M. Gordon. Invocation. Welcome to Chattanooga--Mayor T. C. Thompson. Welcome to her guests from the Chattanooga Equal Suffrage asso- ciation--Margaret H. Ervin, presi- dent. Greetings from Mrs. M. N. Whit- aker, president of Koamos club; Mrs. W. G. Oehmig, vice-president of City Beautiful club; Mr. P. J. Krueal, president of chamber of commerce; Mrs. Medill Mc-Cor- mack, chairman of the congres- sional committee of the National American Woman Suffrage asso- ciation. Responses -- Mrs. Wesley M. Stoner, of Washington, D. C. Appointment of committees. President's address. AFTERNOON 2:30--HOTEL PAT- TEN. Invocation. Amendments to the Constitution. Press conference, led by Ida Por- ter-Boyer. Discussion. 6 to 8 P. M. Banquet honoring prominent vis- itors--Hotel Patten. EVENING 8:30--LYRIC THEATER, CORNER MARKET AND SIXTH STREETS. Invocation. Musical selection. Address--Mrs. Oliver H. P. Bel- mont. Comparisons, 1848 and 1914--Mrs. Nellie Nugent, Somerville, Miss.; Mrs. Hattie Rowland Parker, Louisiana; Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer, Pennsylvania; Miss Laura Clay, Kentucky; Mrs. Harriot Stanton Blatch, New York. Reception--Hotel Patten. The delegates to the Southern States Woman Suffrage conference, which opens for a two days' session tomorrow, are coming in on every train, and it is esti- mated that the late trains this evening will bring in between 100 and 200, includ- ing some of the most distinguished women of the country. For the second time in its existence Chattanooga is an aspirant for a niche in the halls of history. This week's as- semblage of women who are asking for political equality with their husbands and brothers is a historic occasion, and Chattanooga is a milestone in the prog- ress of southern womanhood. The suf- fragists of not only the United States, but twenty-seven foreign countries, will read with eagerness the proceedings of the Southern States Woman Suffrage conference. This conference is linked with the International Woman Suffrage alliance, as well as east, west, north and south throughout this country. The city of Chattanooga is not unmindful of the great advantage she will receive in be- ing the hostess of the suffragists of the south, and the news of its acts goes out into every civilized nation where suf- frage organizations obtain, as well as in homes of every state in the nation. Chattanoogans may feel more than rec- ompensed for the efforts to show ap- preciation for the great honor conferred upon the city. The local association heartily welcomes the members of the Souther States Woman Suffrage conference and the emi- nent suffragists from other sections of the country. Chattanooga has been proudly spurred to hospitable efforts. "A word concerning the most progres- sive and far-seeing organization in the south is in keeping with the city's wel- come," said one of the leaders today. "That woman suffrage is inevitable even the opponents of the movement admit. Twelve states and one territory, Alaska, now admit women to voice their opinions at the ballotbox. These states are west- ern states, save Kansas and Illinois, but the first demand for the ballot for women came from our own southland when Margaret Brent, of Maryland, in 1697, demanded a 'place and voyce' in the colonial assembly. After several hours of heated debate by the men in the as- sembly, Mistress Brent's request was re- fused. These same members of the as- sembly who so arrogantly spurned her demand, on the plea of woman's subor- dinate domestic place, were later obliged to humbly petition Margaret Brent to raise funds to pay the soldiers to pro- tect these very members of the assembly from invasion and spoliation! "Two means of securing the suffrage are open to women. The one by a na- tional constitutional amendment, the other by action of the individual state. While congress is being urged to act, the southern women much prefer to re- ceive the ballot through states rights. Western men have not waited for con- gress to recognize their women, but have gallantly and manfully accorded the pro- tection of the vote to mothers, sisters, wives and daughters, so that the west- ern home is truly a domestic democ- racy. Will it be said that southern men are less chivalrous, that southern women are less deserving than those of the western group? Are southern men con- tent to allow their women to be placed on a political equality with undesirable, disfranchised classes, and are the south- ern women satisfied to remain the un- equals of the men whom they regard? "The Southern States Woman Suffrage conference enlists the co-operation of the thinking men and women to bring about a political equality in southern homes." "The conference will, as stated, include some of the most prominent women of the country, and the conference's busi- ness sessions are to be held in the as- sembly room of the Hotel Patten and the lectures and evening sessions in the Lyric theater. HERALD TALK OF THE TOWN Women will be effective voters in the next municipal campaign. They are making ready for it now. The Boston League of Women Voters is considering how far it should go as an organization in approving or opposing candidates for the city council. The fall conference of the league, with representatives present from each ward and representing all shades of party affiliation, will decide exactly what the league will do. There is no intention or desire to organize a "woman vote" ; in fact, this is to be avoided. The fitness of candidates, however, will interest the league. It is probably that it will be a potent force in the next selection of council members. Very likely knowledge of this fact will influence nominations. Our advice for aspiring politicians is to think this over now. When Mayor Andrew J. Peters hospitably and gracefully entertained the visiting Oxford-Cambridge athletes Thursday noon at luncheon, there was one member of the city government present whose presence was particularly appropriate. This was Councilman Francis Joseph William Ford. Harvard 1904, who attained fame as a broad jumper when at college. It's good training for a man with political aspirations. Mayor Peters, by the way, is a good example of what a man can do in athletics, as well as in other fields, by determination and persistency. Some years ago he made up his mind that he would learn to play a good game of tennis- and he did, by sticking at it and working hard. He is not essentially an athlete, yet he can do many athletic things well. Youngsters might learn a good deal by studying the career of the mayor. He has succeeded by making the best use of all his abilities and opportunities. Fortunate in possessing abilities and brains, Andrew J. Peters has turned his equipment to use. He is an excellent example of achievement of leadership through determination to do so. Mrs. Ida Porter-Boyer, one of the most interesting and one of the most eminent among the country's progressive women, leaves Boston Friday, July 29, for a long trip in the east. She will sail Aug. 5 from San Francisco, and after some time spent in the Philippines will tour China and Japan, returning to the United States not sooner than next March. In the Philippines she will visit her brother-in-law, Col. E. R. Gilson, who has been there since 1913, and who is stationed at Fort Mills, Corrigidor, at the entrance of Manila harbor. In the Philippines Mrs. Boyer will make a thorough study of self-government there and of progress made by the Filipinos, with particular attention to the capacity of the people to carry forward the achievements effected since the American occupation began. She points out that whereas only about 10 per cent. of the people were literate then, now the literacy of the islands is better than in some of our own American southern states. Manila has a very old university; but education used to be for the few. Today it is for all. Mrs. Boyer's sister, Edith Porter Wilson, will accompany her through China and Japan, where Mrs. Boyer will study women's viewpoint in those countries. Most of our news from China and Japan touches commercial and political phases of development. Mrs. Boyer seeks firsthand information on social and sociological conditions, with special reference to women's status and opportunities. The work of Japanese women in Red Cross work, as made evident in the Russo-Japanese war, and which was copied by other countries, has impressed her. She will bring home valuable information concerning what the women of Japan, and of China, have done. This is Mrs. Boyer's sabbatical year. Last September she completed 43 years of active work in behalf of equal suffrage, having begun under the tutelage of Susan B. Anthony. In 1906 she directed the press work for suffrage in Oregon. In 1907 she was in charge of the constitutional convention campaign in Oklahoma. She was associated with Mrs. Harriet Taylor Upton in the campaigning in Ohio. She was in charge of the suffrage campaign which led Michigan to victory for suffrage. To chronicle all her activities would fiill this column. In brief, she has campaigned in every state in the Union except Arizona and New Mexico. For four years she conducted, in New Orleans, the official organ of the Southern States Woman Suffrage Conference, which is believed to have been the only suffrage publication that ever paid in a business way. Mrs. Boyer is a native of Pennsylvania, which may help account for her aptitude for politics. She has for sometime been a powerful factor in the Boston League of Women Voters, and active as a special lecturer on citizenship, etc. her son, John Richard Porter Boyer, graduated from Harvard in 1907. Origin of the Sidesaddle. The use of the sidesaddle for women riders is traced to the time of Anne of Bohemia, eldest daughter of the emperor of Germany, who married Richard II. of England. Previous to this date all Englishwomen bestrode their horse man fashion, but on account of a deformity this German bride was forced to use a sidesaddle, and the custom became general. The Rose Ceremony at Manheim. To the Editor of "The Press" Sir:--Regarding the rose ceremony at Manheim, recently asked about in "The Forum," the town of Manheim, Lancaster County, was founded in 1762 by Henry William Steigel, of Germany, frequently called "Baron" Steigel, but there is no warrant for the title. With the founding of the town Steigel organized a Lutheran congregation and gave the tract of land upon which the church was built. He stipulated that the rental for the land was to be one red red yearly, if the demand for the same was made. The rental was demanded for several years after Steigel's death, but the custom fell into disuse. Fourteen years ago the custom was revived by Dr. J. H. Sieling, then of Manheim, but now located in York, and the services attracted widespread attention. The one red rose was paid to one of the Steigel heirs, of whom there are many in existence, by some prominent man selected for the occasion. The ceremony has been observed since revived by Dr. Sieling, but none will be held this year for the reason that it is not favored by the congregation of the church. While only one rose was demanded in payment for the ground, large contributions of roses were made and these were sent to the sick. "Baron" Steigel not only organized the congregation, but he preached to it. He was not buried at the church and no one to-day knows where his remains were placed. READER. Lancaster, Pa., May 13, 1909. Churches That Pay Their Rent With Roses TWO old churches in Pennsylvania- by the payment of two fresh, Summer roses-have cleaned up their rent until June, 1941, when the annual rental comes due once more. It all happened in a most peculiar way. And it continues to happen every Summer at what has now come to be known as "the feasts of the roses" at Tulpehocken Trinity Reformed Church in Richland, Pennsylvania, and at the Zion Lutheran Church in Manheim, Pennsylvania. Back in 1745, Caspar Wistar, a famous button manufacturer of Philadelphia, set aside 100 acres of ground for religious use. He deeded the church site to the congregation at that time, 195 years ago, and requested that the only compensation for the piece of earth in Richland, Berks County, be one red June rose to be paid to him or to one of his descendants forever. And the bargain, with some exceptions, has been faithfully kept by the Tulpehocken Church, as it is now called, through all the intervening years. This Summer Mrs. Walter Penn Shipley, Jr., of Chestnut Hill, a suburb of the Quaker City, was the recipient of the rental rose. Rev. J. Donald Backenstose, of the church, presided at the colorful ceremony, which included a pageant in which forty members of his flock dramatized the historic story of Regina, the German captive of the Indians. In past years, other descendants have received the rental. Morris Wistar Wood was one of them and Dillwyn Wistar was another. Thomas I. Potts received the payment last year. Sometimes the congregation presents a member of the Wistar family with a whole trellis of roses from which one rose is counted off. Last year, for instance, the 194th rose was counted off and given in payment. This year, a white rose was added to the red rose in gratitude for a huge organ which a group of Casper Wistar's descendants presented to the church several years ago. As for the Zion Lutheran Church, Mrs. Bessie Boyer Van Tassel of Newtownville, Massachusetts, came to receive the rose rental payment, because she is a great-great-granddaughter of William Henry Stiegel, self-styled "Baron" who donated the site for that church in 1772. The "Barron," a glass manufacturer, willed the land to the church for one rose to be paid every year for all time. [* At Least Two Churches in This Country Settle Their Rent for a Year with a Single Rose. *] [* 1940, by American Weekly, Inc. Great Britain Rights Reserved.*] [* 1910 *] THE OKL [?] Helps Rescue Lincoln Disguised From Mob at Harrisburg Memories of the days when president Lincoln's life was threatened and plans were laid by mobs to prevent his arriving in Washington for the second inaugural services are vividly recalled by captain John R. Porter, of Centralia Pa., father of Mrs Ida Porter Boyer. state secretary of the Woman's suffrage league of Oklahoma who is in charge of the state headquarters at the Lee-Huckins. Captain Porter was one of the five men who aided president Lincoln in escaping the mob which had formed at the railroad station in Harrisburg to stop his train. His daughter repeated the story Saturday while discussing the fact that it was the anniversary of Lincoln's birthday. AIDS LINCOLN' ESCAPE. "Father has often told me the story." said Mrs. Boyer, "He was one of the five men who aided president Lincoln to escape from the mob at Harrisburg where it has been believed that he escaped by disguise. He was at that time transcribing clerk in the house of the legislature. The other four were president Thomas Scott of the Pennsylvania railroad. Alexander McClure, editor of the Philadelphia Press; Andrew Curtain, the wartime governor, and Simon Cameron, who was later a member of Lincoln's [* CAPTAIN JOHN R. PORTER. Who Assisted Lincoln to Escape a Harrisburg Mob. *] cabinet. "Lincoln was the gest of the mayor of Harrisburg that day and all arrangements had been made for the train. Word was conveyed to him by some means that plans were on foot to intercept his train when it should arrive at the station. Accordingly the train was run into the freight years and there the president of the United States boarded the train for Washington. FLED IN DISGUISE. "The story has always been told that he escaped in disguise, but he did not. He merely changed hats with Cameron when they left the home of the mayor who suggested that they do that. Lincoln did not want to do so, but the entreaties of the mayor, who did everything in his power to shield Harisburg from the disgrace of having a president killed or mobbed on her streets, won and he consented. He usually wore a large, high crowned stiff hat, such as was worn in those days. He exchanged it for Cameron's felt hat." Captain Porter is a member of the loyal legion to which only ranking officers of the war can belong. His commission was the second on signed by governor Curtain. he organized his company and first enlisted for the three months' service, re-enlisting when that term of enlistment expired. He was presented with a sword for gallant and meritorious conduct at the battle of Antietam. Transcribed and reviewed by contributors participating in the By The People project at crowd.loc.gov.