>> Anne McLean: Good evening. [ Laughter ] Hello. Thank you for coming. I'm Anne McLean from the library music division and we're very excited to welcome back one of the world's great early music ensembles, renowned for 35 years of extraordinary music making, Concerto Koln. It's a pleasure for me to introduce cellist Alexander Scherf, who's the general manager and artistic director, and my colleague Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford, who many of you know, curator of instruments here at the library. And we just had an amazing afternoon, a brief afternoon, exposure for the instruments to these great players and I'll let them talk about that in just a second. We're looking forward tremendously to what I know from experience is going to be a dazzling evening and we wanted to talk about this very interesting program, which is an elegant construction. It's sort of like a set of variations on the concerto form. And we have works coming up; Handle, Bach, Vivaldi, Locatelli, Geminiani, great violinist writing great music that influenced violin writing until today. So, but to start with, why don't you both talk a little bit about this afternoon's visit with our [inaudible] instruments. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: We had an amazing visit. At least I did. I hope you did too. The group came in a couple of hours ago, honestly about two hours ago, and we were in here, and at first I thought just the cellist was going to try the cello of-- from the Library of Congress collection and suddenly we just had glorious sounds coming from the instruments and I have to thank you so much for bringing the group in more-- the violin players tried our instruments and the reason why they tried them is because recently we put some of our [inaudible] instruments in a different setup. You're used to hearing them in a modern setup, with the bridge and steel strings. And in January we had a program here with the Smithsonian called Haydn 2020, where through a generous donor at the Smithsonian we were able to put gut strings and classical or broke bridges on some of our instruments. And so, today, when you showed up, it was one of our, you know, first times really to hear the instruments with your group, which is so phenomenal, the combination, the sound. And so, I-- I want to thank you for that. And before we get more into our instruments, tell me what instruments do you have in your collection? >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah, thanks for having us, that we can come back to the Library of Congress. This is really an honor and thanks for admitting us to have an insight and try out the wonderful instruments of your collection. I mean we aim for an original sound, like the composers in the 18th and early 19th century would have in mind with the instruments. So, it's a mixture between original instruments from this era and newly built modern instruments, which are modeled after original models of the 18th century. So, our-- one of our concert masters, Shunske Sato, he-- he plays a-- an early Flemish violin, which is on loan by a-- by a Dutch society, I think. And [inaudible] Mayumi, the other concert master, she's playing a modern violin, but of course it's-- it's built after Baroque principles [inaudible] Baroque model. So, it's-- it's a blend between the really the original material and newly built instruments after historic models. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: So, that brings us back to today when you showed up. Let's start with the cello. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: That you will hear tonight. He will be playing our cello. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah, the cello is the Castelbarco Stradivari and as I understood it's the first time since ages that there's an original gut string setup on this cello with a historic classical bridge. So, this is wonderful to-- to think of that this might come close to the sound as Stradivari and his contemporaries would have heard that cello. And it's such a released and relaxed and free and warm sound. And I think it's-- it's part of the-- the principle of the gut strings and the lower pitch because it takes away some stress from the instrument and it's not so much pressure on the bridge compared to the modern metal strings. And this makes a really relaxed and big big sound, so big you can hardly tell that they're gut strings. What happens to mic? So, you can hardly tell that there are gut strings on it. It sounds as brilliant and big as a modern concert instrument and this is an amazing experience to me. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: It's true. It does sound that way. Do you find that a lot of modern players today on the cello might prefer the gut strings? >> Alexander Scherf: I mean there's a-- there's a change of taste in the last years. I mean Steven Isserlis, he was always fond of gut strings playing-- playing on gut strings. And the gut strings love him. So, he could even play the Shostakovich Concerto in the Royal Albert Hall in London on gut strings, and you could hear here against modern big size orchestra, which is really amazing. So there-- there-- there are more and more soloists who-- who appreciate the-- the warm and the rich sound of gut strings, again, luckily. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: So, our cello is from 1697, the Castelbarco, and also in the program tonight one of the violinists is going to play on our Castelbarco violin from 1699. Again, in a different setup than it's been used to for as long as I know these instruments have not been in this setup, they have not been performed this way. Of course, they were once that way, and possibly when they first came here in 1935, they were that way. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah. You have to imagine that the-- the use of gut strings was quite common until the second world war. And only after the 40s and the 50s the [inaudible] strings came in use. So, I think the [inaudible] orchestra in Amsterdam was the last orchestra to change from-- from gut to metal not until the 60s or 70s. So, this was-- but-- but we lost this knowledge about playing on gut strings and for using gut strings completely. So, the-- the-- the producers of strings had to-- to learn this craftmanship again. And imagine in those days of Vivaldi and Bach, these strings were more expensive than the actual instrument. The instrument was a piece of wood and this was craftsmanship. And the gut strings, I mean it takes, I think, like 20 or even 30 gut-- guts-- I mean animal intestines to-- to have a double base string. And I think for a cello it's on the-- on the-- on the base strings, it's like 10 or 12 animals you really need for that. And this was really expensive in those days, so the strings were really precious and the instruments, okay, yeah. [ Laughter ] >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: And then also tonight you will hear one of our violas in the same set up. And again, the-- there are musicians on the viola now preferring the gut strings. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah. You are quite right. Even, I mean, especially with string quartets because this is-- the sound of gut strings is maybe not that big as the-- the modern method strings, but it blends more. And the Overton spectrum is-- is richer than-- than those of the metal strings and gives a variety of colors to it and I really do appreciate that. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: I think you'll definitely hear this tonight, the way they blend, in the auditorium, especially in our Coolidge Auditorium. It is just a seamless, gorgeous sound that you're-- from rehearsal. >> Anne McLean: Which-- >> Alexander Scherf: Sorry. >> Anne McLean: So, three of the players and you, right; we have four altogether, four instruments tonight? That's-- that are being-- >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: The Castelbarco violin, the Castelbarco cello, the Tuscan viola. >> Anne McLean: Wonderful. You know, I found this quote about how this ensemble is called the Silver Toned Rolls Royce of period ensembles and I was thinking particularly tonight, this is very [inaudible]. Well let's talk about the program which you put together, which is beautiful and I was curious, do you travel-- first off, do you travel with four violinists very often? I would think this is unusual. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Here. >> Alexander Scherf: I mean we do travel with violinist, but not with four violin soloists. This is something, I mean really something special that we take, let's say, four concert masters with us. I mean Concerto Koln is fairly international orchestra. I mean we're based in Koln, in Germany, but we travel a lot and our concert masters, I mean there's Shunske Sato, he is from a Japanese family but grown up in-- in the U.S. Mayumi from Japan, Evgeny Sviridov from St. Petersburg in Russia, and there's Jesus Merino, a young Spanish violin player who is just new to our ensemble. And this makes it a different blend again. And what we want to show is the-- the development of the Italian concerto form. And of course, Vivaldi is one of the key figures of the concerto form. And the new thing to this Italian model was the juxtaposition of a small concertino, solo playing ensemble, against the Tuttie, the ripieno full orchestra, and probably this came from the Venetian choir tradition where they have some-- several choirs in the [inaudible] cathedral with different sizes. And I think Giuseppe Torelli was the first one to compose systematically with a concertino and a tutti, and of course Vivaldi. And this came a la mode and we know that Vivaldi, he-- he loved arranged-- to arrange pieces by Torelli and by Vivaldi. And especially the concerto for-- for solo violins in B minor we're going to play tonight. There's-- It's an arrangement by Johann Sebastian Bach for [inaudible]. >> Anne McLean: And in fact, arrangements is a theme throughout this. By the way the textures in this program are wonderful and it varies, you know, between solo, ripieno, four violins, two violins, and these are true crowd pleasers, that's for sure, as you'll see. But in terms of arrangements, this is a theme throughout too. The Bach arrangements and the Vivaldi, he made something like nine or 10 of them, of Vivaldi arrangements of his own. And then of course Geminiani was so known for those that he almost became-- over his own music, almost became overshadowed to some degree. So, I was going to ask you to talk about the two that-- Locatelli and Geminiani because each of them, particularly as violinists, as artists, but also as writers of great treatises are so influential. Any-- yeah, tell us a background on them. >> Alexander Scherf: Talking about Francesco Geminiani, he's not such a big name nowadays, compared to his contemporaries, Bach and Handel, which might-- the-- the reason might be that his output is very very little. He didn't compose any operas and his work consists of three or four collections of all instrumental music, mainly violin, [inaudible], Geminiani, he was a [inaudible] player. And by the way, in those days in the [inaudible] only those musicians were considered to be a real musician who were able to compose and to improvise. So, all of them were actually instrumentalists in-- in the first point. And only after that they would compose mainly for their own use. And Geminiani, he-- he was from Lucca in Italy and we know that he has taken up the-- the position of concert master in Naples at the opera orchestra, but only for a couple of months, three or four months, and we wonder why. And I think what-- what I read about Geminiani; he was a maniac somehow. He was over the top; he was crazy and his colleagues couldn't follow his instructions and his bow strokes and you will notice that in-- in his music, especially the-- the late concerto, we recorded them. It's not any more the for-movement structure, slow fast slow fast and it consists of [inaudible], it's rhapsodic and they're concerted by Geminiani which consists of 13-14 very little scenes, so to say. So, it's a-- it's an epic landscape. And this is something very special. And so, his late works were not understood by the amateur music societies [inaudible] and we know that Geminiani he played together with Handel for King George in those days. So, by his colleagues he-- he was considered a big composer, very interesting composer. >> Anne McLean: And there's so many connections like that between-- among the composers on the program that you just were saying, Handel-- the Handel Harpsichord Concerto that you've chosen. This is a piece that was played in between other concerti by Handel himself; it was like an occasional piece sometimes. And in terms of the-- going back to the Bach and Vivaldi connection, I was interested-- I was wondering if you could talk a little bit more about that because you always hear that Bach and-- Bach took a lot from Vivaldi, and you don't know exactly what it-- what it was, maybe. But a couple things popped up today that were interesting, and I wondered if you had read about this. One thing was that Bach may have-- the-- the employer at the time, the Princely Court in Weimar, that prince may have gone to Amsterdam where they just published L'Estro Armonico and that seems a little apocryphal but it's kind of fascinating, that's sort of a concrete bit of information. Is-- what do you hear about that? >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah, I-- I read this also and I know that the-- the prince of Weimar, he-- he went to Amsterdam and there was [inaudible] who published prints, musical prints in Amsterdam. And we know that Vivaldi-- he took Vivaldi to Weimar, and this probably why-- how Bach learned about this music. Also [inaudible], musicologist, he brought the pieces by Torelli to Bach, and [inaudible]. [inaudible] is an important name. He was a violinist in [inaudible] at the [inaudible] court. And he was student of Giuseppe Torelli when Torelli was in Germany. And so, Bach had all those [inaudible] in his library. And the Bach [inaudible] concerto we're going to play tonight, this is pure Italian music basically, but through the intellectual eyes of Johann Sebastian Bach. This is-- this is Italian music basically. >> Anne McLean: Yeah. >> Alexander Scherf: And especially the-- the slow movement, the [inaudible]. And again, the-- the juxtaposition of the lively concertino at the tutti. >> Anne McLean: And another thread going through there is Locatelli because he was one of the people that, as I understand, Bach perf-- chose to program that composer on his coffee house orchestra programs in Leipzig, which are so fascinating and I-- I've been reading-- it's kind of amazing that John Butt was here recently, the scholar and organist, and he was saying in-- that Bach basically worked his way into the position of the leader of the Collegium Musicum. He didn't start out with that, necessarily; it wasn't part of his contract, but he did slowly begin to-- to take over this role and it really broadened his-- his world as a civil servant in the city of Leipzig. But the interesting thing is just that he was able to program something like 500 concerts and Locatelli was one of those. So, did you think of these kinds of connections when you made the program? >> Alexander Scherf: Yes, yes, we do. We find that really interesting. It's still-- for me, it's hard to imagine Bach in the coffee house [laughter]. >> Anne McLean: Yeah. >> Alexander Scherf: In those days, women were not allowed to go to the coffee house, the [inaudible], except for the musical academies, the Collegium Musicum. And you always think Bach-- think of Bach as the composer of [inaudible] passion, the-- the [inaudible] passion and you wouldn't think him entertaining in a coffee house [laughter]. >> Anne McLean: No, you don't. >> Alexander Scherf: But-- but he did that regular seasons. Then he took that over from-- from [inaudible] who founded the Collegium Musicum in Leitzig in those days. And that might be the reason why he arranged and rearranged many many pieces of his [inaudible] in Weimer at the time to have a repertoire for the-- for the coffee house sessions. And he-- of course he changed sacred music into profane music. And had a sacred cantata with a different text and it became the coffee cantata. And-- >> Anne McLean: Yeah. >> Alexander Scherf: And this is-- this was a recycling procedure, which was not to suspect in those days. I mean we-- we think about copyright and copy and paste mistakes and you-- you're refused your doctorate because you did copy and paste, but in those days, it was right-- it was common practice. And when Bach arranged pieces by Vivaldi, it was an homage to the-- to the Italian composer and was an honor to be arranged by one of your fellow composers. >> Anne McLean: You know, we want to find a little bit also about your modern activities and Carol Lynn and I were talking about the Wagner readings you're doing, but just before leaving maybe this, I wanted to ask you about the La Folia, which everyone loves; that's just so famous and so many composers had a crack at it and so on. And I wanted to ask you if you-- what-- were you familiar-- these are all new. [inaudible] list all-- all worked with this too. I didn't know that. I knew about the Italian one, you know, the more-- the well-known ones, Corelli and so on. But apparently many many romantic period composers also worked with this. >> Alexander Scherf: The work with Folia, Folia model. Yeah, the Folia used to be a Spanish part of [inaudible] dance. And it's one of those base lines, [inaudible] base grounds, and many many composers wrote Folia pieces. I mean in the romantic era and even later. And again, this is the concept of Geminiani, he arranged the-- the-- it's a solo violin piece, the Folia by Corelli, and he made it into a concerto [inaudible]. So, he changed the structure. Again, ripieno against a concertino, yeah. But let's talk about the Wagner [laughs]. >> Anne McLean: Yeah. Yeah, the Wagner. We-- Carol Lynn, you probably have some instruments in our collection that would be very relevant to this. The concerto, [inaudible] is doing an amazing project of Wagner readings, which is a multi-year project that I'd like you to describe and then talk more about instruments. >> Alexander Scherf: Early music groups are expanding the-- the repertoires in the-- the last decades and of course the core repertoire for us is the romantic and especially the Italian repertoire. But we-- we-- we play-- of course we play Mozart the classical era, we play Mendinsil, and we did the Brahms German Requiem on period instruments of those days. And our new endeavor is really to have the first ring cycle by Richard Wagner on-- on the appropriate instruments. And so far, I mean we have to find fundings for that, of course, but we did three concerts with romantic repertoire together with Kent Negano [phonetic], who is-- who loves this project and he's conducting and he's the brain of the-- the whole challenge. And the-- the thing is, it's never been done, a ring on the appropriate instruments. And we are-- we are aiming for the [inaudible] setup. There are many many-- there are not that many sources for the premier of the-- the ring, but there are many sources of the premier of [inaudible], which a little later. So, we are aiming for the instruments of the Munich chord orchestra of 1880. And there are many many sources, and we know exactly what wind instruments were used in those days and we know what pitch. This was a [inaudible], this was a pitch 435 [inaudible]. So, nowadays, especially in American orchestras, are really 40-- 43-- 443 [inaudible]. In the [inaudible] age, I mean we use now 414 [inaudible]. So, in those days, the European orchestras agreed, slowly by slowly on a common pitch and this was the-- the [inaudible]. And those instruments mainly don't exist anymore. I mean some early pursuants, original early heckle bassoons we are using them. But we have the oboes rebuilt. This is an instrument maker from Munich in those days, [inaudible], and there are some of those kept in museums of course, but you can't play them anymore. So, we-- we have them rebuilt. So, we-- we're aiming for the original instruments of the Munich [inaudible], which played in [inaudible] in those days. [ Inaudible Response ] >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah, the brass-- it's-- it's a little easier with the brass, because those instruments are playable quite often. But we have to think about the Wagner tubes, Wagner tubin, which is an instrument that Wagner created with instrument makers and this is a really tricky point because the-- the-- the instrument was not perfect in Wagner's day. So, it was a sort of tryout when he employed those instruments in the ring. So, this is where you-- it's research work on-- on that point and there's a-- there's a doctorate and researchers on those topics, the instruments and of course the singers. I mean we are looking for the cast now and the-- the chances to-- to go back to the roots. I mean this is what Kent says. He's done the ring cycle, like 20 or 25 times and he things really this is-- I mean it doesn't make any sense to have the orchestra more bigger and more brilliant and the opera houses grew bigger, and he really wants to go back to the roots and the chances we have an orchestra with period instruments, which make a much more subtle intimate sound then the-- the singles have much more freedom to come across this. And we're not talking about thin voices; it still needs big voices, but they have the chance to focus more and they don't need such a big [inaudible]. And the strings, we are-- we are basically playing non [inaudible] with the romantic repertoire, but have portamento, portamento style. This is to join the-- the-- the notes big gaps and leaps by a subtle glissando, and this is a [inaudible] device, which is widely described in-- in Wagner's and his contemporary. >> Anne McLean: You know, we talked for a moment. I was thinking, if you give your microphone to Carol Lynn, and then I'll pass mine to you. We talked briefly, a moment ago, about you were saying [inaudible] was also interested in the [inaudible] at this time. So, I wanted to start with that. And then Carol Lynn, I wanted to say for you, she's just done a remarkable study. She is in the process of doing a remarkable study of the Leron flutes that the library holds. This is a very scientifically fascinating thing, just as what you're doing with the Wagner. I realize you're also working with your ministry of science and culture in this, which is kind of-- and that's kind of what you're doing. So, I'm going to pass this over. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Well I just want to know after you do your premier of the ring. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Are you going to come to America? I'm sorry you can't do it here in Coolidge Auditorium, but-- >> Alexander Scherf: I mean, we have-- we have presented the project in-- at the Lincoln Center, of course. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Oh okay. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah, but let us practice first [laughter]. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: I'm-- I'm just looking forward to it, to hear it, you know. >> Alexander Scherf: It's an adventure, of course. Yeah. >> Anne McLean: Staging too, right. >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah. >> Anne McLean: You're looking into the whole [inaudible] of everything about it. >> Alexander Scherf: Of course. I mean talking about the vibrato. When Shunske was trying the [inaudible]-- no it was the violin played by Chrysler. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: The Chrysler Guarneri, yes. >> Alexander Scherf: The Chrysler Guarneri. He employed very little vibrato. I mean, nowadays when you watch the-- the modern symphony orchestra they have a permanent vibrato and quite-- quite wide, quite big. And in those days the vibrato was really narrow, in a way, and more focused. And he-- Shunske can really do that. I mean he's able to have many varieties of vibrato. And of course, the soloists, they use vibrato. I was talking about the-- the orchestra style. And we found sources that show clearly that vibrato in the orchestra, in the tutti section, was only used when-- when it said dolce or espressivo. This was a sign of employed vibrato. But apart from that, it's-- it's a non-vibrato sound. >> Anne McLean: Carol Lynn, is the cello about your-- a little bit of your scientific study? >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Yeah, I don't want to-- I just had one more-- I had to do a shout out to Thomas Jefferson though, we have to tell you that in the Jefferson Library here, at the Library of Congress, there's a Geminiani , the art of playing on the violin. We have that copy that was Thomas Jefferson's; he was a violin player. And there's an annotation by Bernie in that book. Just my little plug for-- for-- >> Alexander Scherf: It's important violin school by Geminiani. Of course, we have read that, yeah, but, I-- no touch to the original. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: We have the original copy here, the many riches. >> Anne McLean: And so, the-- one question we-- we both had, sort of, in mind for you is what is the role of a period instrument in this-- at this time? What is your next move and so on? >> Alexander Scherf: You mean what-- >> Anne McLean: For you. >> Alexander Scherf: What are we aiming for? >> Anne McLean: Concerto Koln. Yeah, what will be your next ventures? >> Alexander Scherf: I mean, we always try to have composers back on stage, which are not known. We're doing research work now on Sammartini, which is a composer between the Baroque and the classic era. And yeah, of course we do the-- we do play the main repertoire, but still there's-- there's something to explore. I mean the-- the amount of improvisation, this is a thing that musicologists must be aware of that-- in those days the soloists used to improvise. You can hear that in the organ concerto, which is played on the harpsicord tonight by [inaudible]. And you-- you-- sadly it was actually some [inaudible] played between the acts of a Handel opera in the opera house was incidental music. And they're written parts or printed parts with the orchestra parts and the-- the solo part is only the few bars, the few measures, and then it's nothing. And this shows that Handel loved to improvise-- improvise his solo line. And our [inaudible] harpsicord player, he does a little improvisation in-- in the beginning of the concerto and the slow movement, he basically improvises. And so, we-- we think the written music, which came upon us is-- is only a framework we have to fill with-- with flesh. And so, it's-- to our taste, it's no point to play note by note as written in the-- in this [inaudible]. No Baroque [inaudible] would have done that. So, we-- we have-- we're looking for own-- our own interpretations and this is a pretty big amount of improvising, yes. >> Anne McLean: It's amazing really what-- what you take on, how you continue to grow and make all these new ventures and ideas, explorations. You have an extraordinarily-- you have an extraordinary explorer spirit in your-- in your ensemble. So back to the instruments just for a moment. When-- is-- would it have been a normal thing for players to swap off like this, I mean this is pretty rare? You're very daring guys to-- >> Alexander Scherf: I mean, in a way it's daring to play those fine instruments tonight in a concert with just a half an hour-- >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: You're Italian, we had to keep the whole-- >> Alexander Scherf: Rehearsal, so this is a daring thing. And I-- I'm sure it needs much more time, hours and hours work to explore the-- the range of the Stradivari cello of course, so this is just an experiment [laughs]. >> Anne McLean: But they really pay off. They really pay-- no, I mean I'm teasing you, but if anyone can do this beautifully-- >> Alexander Scherf: Thanks. Thanks. >> Anne McLean: Of course, but in your experience, Carol Lynn, when people pick them up who are masters of this technique and so on, regardless of the setup and so on, don't they just respond more-- >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Absolutely. I mean, you came in here within minutes, you know, you had-- you were exploring the sound on each note, on each string. You were just listening, you know, so intently, and you spent like 20 minutes really understanding. But there was no-- no doubt in your mind once you started playing it and you were here, just rehearsing with it, and then you looked up and said can I play it tonight. You know, it just-- it-- it worked. There wasn't-- with you. And I found that a lot with the cello in particular. I don't know. How did you feel-- like when did you feel like-- I mean it must be a daunting thing to come here, show up and say, oh, can I play on this instrument, you know? >> Alexander Scherf: It is a daring thing. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: No, not daring, daunting. >> Alexander Scherf: I shouldn't do that, but. I mean playing on an instrument like that is-- is a lifelong journey of course, to explore the possibilities and it's like a marriage isn't it [laughter]. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Yeah. >> Anne McLean: Yes, exactly. >> Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford: Quite a dance. >> Anne McLean: Well I know that Alexander has to prepare to perform. I just-- if we could take maybe just two questions, and then we could let him get-- yeah. Anybody have a particular one in mind? >> Alexander Scherf: Yes please. >> Anne McLean: Someone. >> Speaker 4: Can you tell us some more about what period [inaudible] what the difference-- what the difference would be between that and a modern violin, say? >> Alexander Scherf: Yeah. So, the-- they're played the same instruments we do. I mean they're-- they played instruments from the Baroque age, from the classical age. They still had gut strings, but I'm talking about the cello, the top two strings are blank gut strings and the two base strings are wound with-- with a silver wire, which became flat after a while. The cellos had-- some had still no spike, no end pin. Some had that already. This was a time of change, so there were orchestra players who were old-fashioned in a way who kept playing without spike and who kept the-- the old classical bows and the way of playing, and there were players who, of course, used the-- the now modern bow who used an end pin. To-- to prepare for the Wagner project we-- we analyzed the early videos. I mean you have them all on YouTube. You have a-- the sound, you have your [inaudible] on YouTube, the early [inaudible]. You have the [inaudible] and even there are some videos, early videos from I think the 20s from Dresden and from Munich. And you can tell what player is, in a way, old-fashioned, and the players who adapted to the modern technique. So, this is-- it was not that uniform then in a modern orchestra nowadays. But we-- we are doing that-- we're doing that, the top strings, gut strings without wire and the bottom strings with wire. And we have an early modern bow. Yeah. >> Anne McLean: Thank you. >> Speaker 5: I wanted to ask you how [inaudible] a lot of institutions and it seems like you have more people to choose from. It's been a practice of Americans in the opera world going to Europe to develop their skills and they return to the United States. Are you seeing a similar sort of movement like that and when it comes to early-- early music? Because we're really kind of restricted to east coast, the west coast and a couple of islands between here and there [laughter] sort of thing. And, you know, you come here with a lot of depth behind you. How do you see the [inaudible]? You can say profession of early music performance. >> Alexander Scherf: I think nowadays young musicians who embark for a professional career they can really choose what style of playing they want to learn. And luckily there are many colleges now who have an early music department. I mean back like 30-40 years, there were only two beacon colleges. This was Amsterdam, maybe the Hake [phonetic], and Basel in Switzerland who were really busy with the research and early music. But nowadays there are many colleges in-- in Germany and Europe who offer an early music course. I mean, of course, England was always on the front of early music, but now it's Cologne and Munich, Leitzg, Berlin. You can-- you can study period instruments there, and I think the Julliard school has its early music department since 10 years now. >> Speaker 5: Yeah. >> Alexander Scherf: So, you are-- you are having a development in the United States [laughter]. >> Anne McLean: Very much. >> Alexander Scherf: I mean playing the-- I [inaudible] to us now, the U.S. with his Beethoven cycle. And I think this is done for the first time. I mean he does in a row; in three or four days he does all the Beethoven symphonies in Chicago and I don't know where else. This is the first time it's done in the-- in the U.S., yes. >> Speaker 5: But you see good development in schools. Students are signing up to take the programs. They think they can make a go of it and make a living of it. >> Alexander Scherf: I mean to make a living from that, I mean you have to be very flexible and many-- many players are really able to-- to swap between the modern metal strings and on the other night they play the gut strings. I think you have to be-- to have to have this flexibility, yeah. But I mean the orchestras and the modern symphony orchestra are open to early music conductors. They invite [inaudible] or Gardiner are invited to perform classical or even a Baroque program within a symphony orchestra. So there-- there are not borders anymore between those two ways of performing, luckily. Luckily. >> Anne McLean: Yes, [inaudible] is an amazing conductor here recently with the NSO. It was just marvelous and he brought out all these things you never hear that in a-- in a normal performance with regular conductors. Well I think that might do it, maybe. What do you think Alex? >> Alexander Scherf: Thanks a lot for having me, yeah. Thanks a lot. [ Applause ]